The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 Andrew Joyce Archive
Is Jewish Leftism a ‘Reform Problem’?
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

“What Reform did not do, any more than the ‘Science of Judaism,’ was to solve the Jewish problem.” Paul Johnson, A History of the Jews, 1987.

Sparked by Tucker Carlson’s remarkable move towards the Jewish Question, the recent condemnation of the ADL issued by 1,500 rabbis associated with the Coalition for Jewish Values (CJV) has once more raised the question as to whether destructive activity perpetrated by Jewish activists in America is a matter of denomination rather than ethnicity. For several years now, but increasing during the early Trump years, there’s been a quiet but growing argument from self-styled ‘right-wing Jews’ that Jewish leftist activists are anathema to Judaism, or that as adherents of the Reform movement or Liberal Judaism they are a variety of heretical neo-Frankists unrepresentative of “true Jews.” Underlying these arguments is the implication that anti-Semitic theories involving Jews as an ethnic group, perceived as uniform, rely on weak generalizations that do not take into account the political and cultural nuances of American Jews, and therefore that such theories are illogical and irrational. In the course of almost a decade of writing about anti-Semitism and historical and contemporary Jewish behavior among Europeans, I’ve addressed this issue of political nuance more or less directly in a number of essays, especially my discussion of Jewish attitudes to Brexit and Jewish Leftist activism in children’s fiction. Given the quite dramatic nature of this most recent intervention from a signification number of rabbis against one of the world’s most prominent Jewish organizations, however, I think it’s an appropriate time to tackle the subject directly.

Before beginning, it’s worth reflecting on the context of the initial contention made by self-styled right-wing Jews. These Jews, one of the most prominent being Nathan Cofnas, make the argument that Jewish involvement in the advancement of Leftism in the West is both limited (in the sense that the advancement of Leftism also involves massive numbers of Whites and other ethnic groups), and is a predominantly Reform affair, whereas Orthodox and Ultra-Orthodox Jews have a different socio-political direction entirely. In regards to the first element, the ‘limits’ of Jewish involvement, there are few, if any, anti-Jewish theories in circulation which ascribe to Jews sole responsibility for the entirety of contemporary leftist activism. What does exist, however, is a substantial volume of evidence demonstrating that individuals who self-identify as Jews have been over-represented as innovators, leaders, and funders of the modern Left, and this evidence has led to the logical and tactical adoption of an anti-Jewish political position by many conservative Europeans and those of European ancestry. To put it simply, Jews don’t need to be orchestrating a kind of solo conspiracy against the West for an anti-Semitic political position to make theoretical sense and be supported by the data, or for Jewish influence to be a reasonable and rational topic of public discussion.

In regards to the second element of the ‘right-wing Jewish’ contention, it should be understood that the trajectory of the argument is essentially diversionary. When I first read the “not all Jews” argument being employed by Cofnas against Kevin MacDonald, for example, I was immediately reminded of the historical framework of prior debates in which minor concessions on the Jewish Question appear to be made, but are then narrowed and finally diverted. Relevant examples can be found in the public debates between Christian Wilhelm Von Dohm and Moses Mendelssohn[1]Crouter, Richard. “Emancipation Discourse in the Late 18th Century: Christian Wilhelm von Dohm on the Jews (1781)” Journal for the History of Modern Theology, vol. 13, no. 2, 2006, pp. 161-178. For translated primary sources on the debate between the two intellectuals see Mendes-Flohr, Paul R. (ed) The Jew in the Modern World: A Documentary History (New York: Oxford University Press, 1980), pp. 27-43., and between Karl Marx and Bruno Bauer.[2]See on this topic, Peled, Yoav. “From theology to sociology: Bruno Bauer and Karl Marx on the question of Jewish emancipation.” History of Political Thought 13, no. 3 (1992): 463-485; Blanchard, William H. “Karl Marx and the Jewish question.” Political Psychology (1984): 365-374; Leopold, David. “The Hegelian Antisemitism of Bruno Bauer.” History of European ideas 25, no. 4 (1999): 179-206. In both cases, which concerned the question of Jewish political emancipation, and the undesirability of such an event in the context of negative Jewish group behavior, the Jewish participants attempted to rhetorically carve off elements of the Jewish population, scapegoating them temporarily in order that broader Jewish goals (social, political, or economic) might be achieved. Both Mendelssohn and Marx conceded that harms were being wrought by Jews, but added that this was the result of historical mistreatment that produced a class of renegade Jews (crooks and usurers for Mendelssohn; arch-capitalists for Marx). The fundamental goal of these rhetorical strategies was to defuse and weaken the anti-Semitic reaction, with both Mendelssohn and Marx keen to ease the Jewish path to full civic equality in Europe.

The modern version of these strategies appears to be the insistence that historical treatment (exclusion from the Right[3]Although ‘right-wing’ Jews like Cofnas seem unaware of it, they’re actually regurgitating an old-fashioned and now more or less discredited theory of Jewish liberalism. See, for example, the work of Werner Cohn in the late 1950s, where he often argued that Jews had been ‘pushed’ to the left by the association of the right with anti-Semitism.) and contemporary circumstances (tendencies in Western liberalism) have created a Frankenstein’s monster in the form of a radical left Reform Judaism. While right-wing Jews are comfortable, to an extent, in condemning these radical Reform Jews, they insist that the host population should remain tolerant of the Jewish ethnic group as a whole and to continue to support Israel. The crucial point here is that, because of its diversionary nature, and its quite obvious side-stepping of the cost-benefit implications of philo-Semitic tolerance (as if European problems with Jews and Judaism have ever been limited to postmodern Leftism), it is inherently political to ask if Jewish Leftism is a Reform problem. It is nevertheless interesting to ask, given that it interrogates the framing of anti-Semitism and opens up valid questions about the Jewish relationship to the Left, and about the nature of the Jewish-European conflict more generally. Most pertinently we should ask, even if Jewish Leftism is a Reform problem, does it ultimately matter?

Gaining conclusive and detailed insight into the socio-political leanings of contemporary American Jews is difficult. Part of this difficulty lies in historical Jewish evasiveness when it comes to, for example, being counted in national censuses, and more general suspicions that data collected on Jews will inevitably be used against them by the host population.[4]For a more detailed discussion of these difficulties see DellaPergola, Sergio, “Jewish Demography: Fundamentals of the Research Field,” in Rebhun, Uzi, The Social Scientific Study of Jewry: Sources, Approaches, Debates (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014). Also of interest in the same volume is Saxe, Leonard et al, “Measuring the Size and Characteristics of American Jewry: A New Paradigm for an Ancient People.” When Jewish organizations conduct their own surveys of political, social, or cultural attitudes, the direction of analysis is overwhelmingly against the host population. In fact, surveys of alleged anti-Semitism in the host population are extremely common, if not the most common type of social survey conducted by Jewish groups.[5]Smith, Tom W. “A Review: Actual Trends or Measurement Artifacts? A Review of Three Studies of Anti-Semitism.” The Public Opinion Quarterly 57, no. 3 (1993): 380-93. Scholars have pointed out that in those instances where Jewish groups engage in surveys among their own people, these surveys are overwhelmingly concerned with population size and Jewish identity, and are often loaded with agendas, biases, and goals such as the boosting of Jewish fertility and the reduction of intermarriage rates.[6]DellaPergola, Sergio, “Jewish Demography: Fundamentals of the Research Field”, 10 & 23. Such studies can, for example, be designed to “greatly exaggerate” notions of Jewish population decline in order to promote endogamy and increase Jewish fertility. Furthermore, in those instances when Jews have conducted social research on themselves as a means of ‘explaining’ themselves to host peoples, this has also been warped by ulterior and often apologetic motives. Hebrew University’s Sergio DellaPergola, for example, has argued that “Jewish social research was never the mere exercise of human curiosity or analytical skill. Rather it was a means of advancing specific theses regarding the nature of the Jews vis-a-vis world society.”[7]Ibid., 15.
(DellaPergola, Sergio, “Jewish Demography: Fundamentals of the Research Field”, 10 & 23. Such studies can, for example, be designed to “greatly exaggerate” notions of Jewish population decline in order to promote endogamy and increase Jewish fertility.)
All of which is to say that survey data and social research concerning Jews should be treated with an appropriate level of caution.

It’s nevertheless clear that gaining some kind of reliable insight into the political positions and divisions of American and Western Jewry is important, if not crucial, for host nations. Since their earliest arrival in Europe, Jews have been noted as influential political actors in Western nations, and in recent decades this influence has extended even to the manipulation of the demography of those countries. DellaPergola, for example, has argued that Jewish populations “may significantly influence national population trends in order to advance their own corporate interests — for example, by advocating particular policy interventions.”[8]Ibid., 17.
(DellaPergola, Sergio, “Jewish Demography: Fundamentals of the Research Field”, 10 & 23. Such studies can, for example, be designed to “greatly exaggerate” notions of Jewish population decline in order to promote endogamy and increase Jewish fertility.)
DellaPergola notes that Jewish populations can often be divided into at least two categories: the core Jewish population of strongly-identified, full-blooded, and often religious, Jews; and the ‘enlarged Jewish population’ which embraces all those with at least some Jewish ethnic heritage that they have consciously embraced, as well as those full-blooded Jews of a less religious inclination but who see themselves as part of a Jewish peoplehood. It’s important to stress at this stage that both divisions are fully capable of formulating and pursuing ideas of what constitutes “corporate interests,” even differing ideas, since the ultimate corporate body in both divisions is not Judaism as such but the Jewish people or even merely the idea of the Jewish people and its putative destiny.

One of the weaknesses of DellaPergola’s division of contemporary Jewry is its lack of utility in the religious sense. Orthodox and Reform Jews can only be roughly mapped onto “core” and “enlarged” categories because, in an American context in which Reform Jews are certainly an influential demographic majority, it makes little sense to argue that they are not in fact the “core” of the American Jewish community. This is where the argument of the self-styled right-wing Jews encounters its first major stumbling block, because the attempt to defend Jews in toto by scapegoating Reform Jews misses the point that Reform, for all intents and purposes, is American Jewry and will remain so demographically far into the future.[9]Although having a higher birth rate, Orthodox Jews comprise only around 10 percent of American Jewry, and around 10 percent of Orthodox youth eventually drift into more liberal Jewish milieus or forms of Judaism. The decline of the Reform population via intermarriage has rightly been described as “greatly exaggerated” by Calvin Goldscheider. See Goldscheider, Calvin, Studying the Jewish Future (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2004). XXXXXX

The “core” and “enlarged” categories are, however, of some interest and utility when discussing survey data on Jewish political attitudes. It’s been noted that most exit polls will collect reasonably accurate data on “core” Jews because they capture “Jews by Religion” (JBR) when asking if voters are Protestant, Catholic, Jewish, etc. The “core” Jewish population is more likely to include the more religiously identified Orthodox Jews, but it’s interesting that most recent exit polls (conducted by Pew Research) continue to show that even in the JBR category the party split was 68 percent Democratic, 7 percent Independent, and 25 percent Republican. Figures for “Jews of No Religion” (JNR) were 78 percent, 10 percent, and 12 percent. More than 40 percent of JBRs described themselves as liberal, while only 22 percent described themselves as conservative. The rest indicated only that they were moderate, which is open to any number of interpretations. Herbert Weisberg, writing in The Annual Jewish Year Book 2019 explained the figures as indicating that “Jews should be considered to be more Democratic and more liberal than media surveys and exit polls typically show.”[10]Weisberg, Herbert. F. “The Presidential Voting of American Jews,” in Sheskin, Ira (ed), American Jewish Yearbook 2019 (New York: Springer, 2020), 43. This would seem to be indicated also by a number of J Street exit polls which showed that Orthodox Jews are more liberal than ‘right-wing’ Jewish diversionists would have us believe. More than half of Orthodox Jews (59 percent), for example, voted for Obama in 2012, and a similar proportion (56 percent) voted for Clinton in 2016.[11]Ibid., 82.
(Weisberg, Herbert. F. “The Presidential Voting of American Jews,” in Sheskin, Ira (ed), American Jewish Yearbook 2019 (New York: Springer, 2020), 43.)
Even among the Ultra-Orthodox, normally viewed as overwhelmingly hawkish and likely to vote along with the flamboyant Zionism of the GOP, more than a third of respondents (35 percent) to one poll described themselves as Democrats.[12]Ibid., 77.
(Weisberg, Herbert. F. “The Presidential Voting of American Jews,” in Sheskin, Ira (ed), American Jewish Yearbook 2019 (New York: Springer, 2020), 43.)

It’s important to note that the Jewish political profile is unique. While attempts have been made, by diversionists like Cofnas, to explain Jewish liberalism as an aspect of their higher educational attainment or their likelihood to be more urban-dwelling, serious scholars of Jewish demography and politics have long noted that “studies consistently find that Jews are significantly more Democratic than non-Jews with similar socio-demographic characteristics … Indeed, Wald’s calculations show they are more Democratic than the non-Jew who is their closest match on demographics and economic status.”[13]Ibid., 73.
(Weisberg, Herbert. F. “The Presidential Voting of American Jews,” in Sheskin, Ira (ed), American Jewish Yearbook 2019 (New York: Springer, 2020), 43.)
Wald and Weisberg instead argue that all Jews, whether Orthodox or Reform, “core” or “enlarged,” will vote or engage politically as part of a reaction to “the greatest perceived threat to their interests.”[14]Ibid., 46.
(Weisberg, Herbert. F. “The Presidential Voting of American Jews,” in Sheskin, Ira (ed), American Jewish Yearbook 2019 (New York: Springer, 2020), 43.)
In other words, Jewish political behavior is best explained by Jewish agency and perceptions of Jewish interests rather than cultural context.

It’s arguable that two of the most important Jewish interests are in the form of socio-economic dominance and multiculturalism, and here the unique pattern of Jewish political activity continues and amplifies. It’s extremely interesting that Jews very heavily support non-economic forms of leftism, and are very much in favor of the expansion of government power, but are much more reluctant to back purely economic forms of socialism. In this regard they differ significantly from non-Jewish leftists who embrace and emphasize economic socialism within their worldview. A 2012 survey found that a majority of Jews were not willing to pay more taxes in order to help the poor, were not likely to support a government health scheme, and were generally not supportive of government economic guarantees.[15]Weisberg, Herbert F. The Politics of American Jews (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2019),127-128. Jews have also been noted in the past as strong opponents of affirmative action, with even the ADL and the American Jewish Committee filing briefs against it.[16]Van Horne, Winston A. Ethnicity in the Work Force (Milwaukee: University of Wisconsin Press, 1985), 56. This can be easily interpreted not as a method of opposing race politics, but as a means of preventing incursion into, or a breaking up of, established Jewish dominance within the professions. This would indicate that Jerry Muller’s theory that Jews have long had a “special relationship” with capitalism,[17]See Jerry Z. Muller, Capitalism and the Jews (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2010).

[18] Jack Dalton, “’Be Brave, Do Something’: Ashley Rae Goldenberg’s List of Corporations that Support the Riots asnd Want You Dead,” VDare (June 6, 2020). https://vdare.com/posts/be-brave-do-something-ashley...u-dead
continues to have resonance despite the leadership of Jews in the onward march of purely cultural and political forms of leftism—now championed by large swaths of other elite sectors of America, including large corporations.[18] The general image that emerges is one in which Jews act politically to create socially and culturally fluid societies where a facade of social justice and equality is promoted and celebrated, and in which a pseudo-elite (Whites) is attacked, but in which no real threat to Jewish privileges and socio-economic dominance is present.

Jews also quite obviously have a special relationship with multiculturalism, being Europe’s first significant minority and the passive or active cause of most of the continent’s earliest legislation on tolerance and migration. It’s an unfortunate commonplace that many of those who have criticized Kevin MacDonald for suggesting that Jews promote multiculturalism in order to feel more secure, are completely ignorant of the fact that several of his ideas are in some form or another slowly becoming fairly mainstream in the sociological study of contemporary Jews. Historian Diana Pinto, a Jewish Harvard graduate, Fulbright Fellow, and board member for the Institute for Jewish Policy Research, has argued that, within a multicultural context, “Jews are no longer perceived as the only ‘diasporic’ people, or as the most significant ‘other’ in the society,” and that this “relieves Jews of burden.”[19]Quoted in Hartman, Harriet, “Studies of Jewish Identity and Continuity: Competing, Complementary, and Comparative Perspectives,” in Rebhun, Uzi, The Social Scientific Study of Jewry: Sources, Approaches, Debates (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014), 93. Any scenario in which the pluralistic principles of the host nation are fundamentally challenged, or in which demographic change could return Jews to a position of ‘burden,’ would therefore quite obviously represent a perceived threat to Jewish interests along the lines discussed by Wald and Weisberg, and the question of immigration and associated laws would be an area of political activity that one would expect to see high levels of Jewish participation. Jewish opinions on threat level can of course vary, with some Jews feeling content and secure with moderate levels of pluralism while others would feel secure only when the demographic dominance of the host population is completely undermined. If a proportion of the immigrating demographic is itself a perceived threat to Jews, for example in the case of Muslim migration to France and other parts of Europe, further division and divergence would be expected. The most important aspect of the topic, however, remains that Jews have a fundamental interest in preserving the pluralistic principles of the host nation and avoiding a return of the Jews to a position of being a salient ‘other,’ and therefore a ‘burden.’ In this respect, much as with the nature of Jewish leftism in relation to economic and social questions, the Jewish relationship to multiculturalism is unique, and involves a blurring of the standard left-right political categories that can be more crudely applied to non-Jewish political activity.

The apparent clash between the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) and the Coalition for Jewish Values (CJV) over Tucker Carlson presents an interesting case in which fundamental agreement on Jewish interests can be overlaid with disagreement between fringe cliques of Jews and the great majority of Jewish population on how to best achieve those interests. The first point worth stressing is that the incident is not a straightforward case of Orthodox versus Reform. The Coalition for Jewish Values is, as far as I am aware, exclusively staffed by Orthodox and Ultra-Orthodox Jews who can be usefully described as “core” Jews. The ADL, however, cannot be neatly categorized as a Reform organization, because its most recent Directors have been Orthodox (Abe Foxman, Director 1987–2015) and Conservative (Jonathan Greenblatt, Director 2015–present), and because its behavior since its founding can be most accurately described as an expression of the “enlarged” Jewish population rather than any specific denomination within that. Further, the motivations and past actions of the CJV map comfortably within a reasonable conception of Jewish interests rather than being a novel break from them. And finally, in all such cases of division within the Jewish community, it’s important to assess where the power lies if one is attempting to discern relative influence on the wider society. The ADL, representing the interests of the “enlarged” Jewish population, is far more powerful and influential than CJV.

Even aside from the fact that they emerged from the momentum of Trumpist Zionism, it’s interesting that the CJV has rationalized its more socially conservative positions via the lens of Jewish interests. When the group filed an amicus brief in support of Christian groups fighting to keep a large cross placed on public grounds in Pensacola, Florida, for example, the CJV claimed that ruling against the right to place a cross would also “encourage the erasure of minority religions from public life.” In other words, they viewed their actions primarily as protecting Judaism and pluralistic principles in the host society, even if this commitment to pluralistic principles has not extended, as in the case of the “enlarged Jewish community,” to gays and transsexuals. The CJV may also be a response of sorts to increasing awareness among conservative Whites (like Tucker Carlson) that Jews occupy a very unique and prominent role in American leftism. This increasing visibility would obviously be perceived as a threat by Jews. Yaakov Menken, the CJV’s managing director, has recalled a conversation with a Christian pro-Israel leader who told him: “I can’t tell you how often people ask me “‘why are you devoting so much time to supporting the Jews and Israel when Jews oppose us on our core issues?’” The potential collapse of Christian Zionism and philo-Semitism in America would obviously have significant consequences for Jewish influence globally, and it should therefore come as no surprise that an effort to heighten the visibility of a “right-wing Judaism” would be made, no matter how superficial or self-interested.

Concluding Remarks

Is Jewish leftism a Reform problem? No. The Orthodox and Ultra-Orthodox have their own history of endorsing and supporting leftism if it suited Jewish interests, motivated by their attempting to avoid or lessen perceived threats. Moreover, even if Jewish leftism was a Reform problem, the broader causes of anti-Semitism wouldn’t evaporate with the disappearance of that denomination. The Reform movement, we should recall, began in the nineteenth century — around 2,000 years after the earliest writings against the Jewish people. Many of the major historical provocations of anti-Semitic attitudes such as high levels of Jewish ethnocentrism, Jewish economic domination and exploitation, and the special political relationship between Jews and elites, cross denominational lines and precede by centuries the emergence of the modern left. Some aspects of problematic contemporary Jewish behavior such as slumlordism, fraud, and white-collar crime are actually found in higher numbers among the Orthodox and Ultra-Orthodox than among Reform Jews.[20]See, for example, Rosen, Michael, “God Will Not Provide: Hasidic Jews and Fraud.” Journal of Law & Social Deviance 3 (2012): 245.

In short, the case for an ethnic interpretation of Jewish behavior far outweighs that for a denominational perspective. In the end, the diversionary argument of the self-styled right-wing Jews can only gain traction among those whose worldview is simplistic and without nuance, and who perceive all of contemporary politics under the basic rubric of Left versus Right. Among such people, it’s perfectly possible to look at the handful of anti-transsexual or anti-ADL statements of the CJV and conclude that one has an ideological brother. Among the more sophisticated, however, in which a definite sense of ethnic interests is foremost, a more nuanced approach emerges, along with a new question altogether: For how long will the politics of my nation turn on the axis of Jewish interests?

Notes

[1] Crouter, Richard. “Emancipation Discourse in the Late 18th Century: Christian Wilhelm von Dohm on the Jews (1781)” Journal for the History of Modern Theology, vol. 13, no. 2, 2006, pp. 161-178. For translated primary sources on the debate between the two intellectuals see Mendes-Flohr, Paul R. (ed) The Jew in the Modern World: A Documentary History (New York: Oxford University Press, 1980), pp. 27-43.

[2] See on this topic, Peled, Yoav. “From theology to sociology: Bruno Bauer and Karl Marx on the question of Jewish emancipation.” History of Political Thought 13, no. 3 (1992): 463-485; Blanchard, William H. “Karl Marx and the Jewish question.” Political Psychology (1984): 365-374; Leopold, David. “The Hegelian Antisemitism of Bruno Bauer.” History of European ideas 25, no. 4 (1999): 179-206.

[3] Although ‘right-wing’ Jews like Cofnas seem unaware of it, they’re actually regurgitating an old-fashioned and now more or less discredited theory of Jewish liberalism. See, for example, the work of Werner Cohn in the late 1950s, where he often argued that Jews had been ‘pushed’ to the left by the association of the right with anti-Semitism.

[4] For a more detailed discussion of these difficulties see DellaPergola, Sergio, “Jewish Demography: Fundamentals of the Research Field,” in Rebhun, Uzi, The Social Scientific Study of Jewry: Sources, Approaches, Debates (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014). Also of interest in the same volume is Saxe, Leonard et al, “Measuring the Size and Characteristics of American Jewry: A New Paradigm for an Ancient People.”

[5] Smith, Tom W. “A Review: Actual Trends or Measurement Artifacts? A Review of Three Studies of Anti-Semitism.” The Public Opinion Quarterly 57, no. 3 (1993): 380-93.

[6] DellaPergola, Sergio, “Jewish Demography: Fundamentals of the Research Field”, 10 & 23. Such studies can, for example, be designed to “greatly exaggerate” notions of Jewish population decline in order to promote endogamy and increase Jewish fertility.

[7] Ibid., 15.

[8] Ibid., 17.

[9] Although having a higher birth rate, Orthodox Jews comprise only around 10 percent of American Jewry, and around 10 percent of Orthodox youth eventually drift into more liberal Jewish milieus or forms of Judaism. The decline of the Reform population via intermarriage has rightly been described as “greatly exaggerated” by Calvin Goldscheider. See Goldscheider, Calvin, Studying the Jewish Future (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2004).

[10] Weisberg, Herbert. F. “The Presidential Voting of American Jews,” in Sheskin, Ira (ed), American Jewish Yearbook 2019 (New York: Springer, 2020), 43.

[11] Ibid., 82.

[12] Ibid., 77.

[13] Ibid., 73.

[14] Ibid., 46.

[15] Weisberg, Herbert F. The Politics of American Jews (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2019),127-128.

[16] Van Horne, Winston A. Ethnicity in the Work Force (Milwaukee: University of Wisconsin Press, 1985), 56.

[17] See Jerry Z. Muller, Capitalism and the Jews (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2010).

[18] Jack Dalton, “’Be Brave, Do Something’: Ashley Rae Goldenberg’s List of Corporations that Support the Riots asnd Want You Dead,” VDare (June 6, 2020). https://vdare.com/posts/be-brave-do-something-ashley-rae-goldenberg-s-list-of-corporations-that-support-the-riots-and-want-you-dead

[19] Quoted in Hartman, Harriet, “Studies of Jewish Identity and Continuity: Competing, Complementary, and Comparative Perspectives,” in Rebhun, Uzi, The Social Scientific Study of Jewry: Sources, Approaches, Debates (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014), 93.

[20] See, for example, Rosen, Michael, “God Will Not Provide: Hasidic Jews and Fraud.” Journal of Law & Social Deviance 3 (2012): 245.

(Republished from The Occidental Observer by permission of author or representative)
 
• Category: History, Ideology • Tags: ADL, American Jews, Jews 
Hide 126 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
    []
  1. Chris Moore says: • Website

    Are “progressive” Judeofascists the problem, and “conservative” Judeofascists the solution? Was ((neoconservatism)) the solution to ((Bolshevism))?

  2. I appreciate your efforts, Mr. Joyce, to present an academically fair breakdown of the problem you attack. The possible distinctions between liberal and conservative Jews are certainly worth considering. However, let me please, as a born and raised Jew, break down the problem in much cruder terms. For I fear that in analyzing the “trees” we really do lose sight of the “forest.”

    Thus: Everything that occurs in the world is seen through the lens of “Is it good for the Jews?” With respect to the United States and Jewish loyalty thereto, the interests of the Jews and, by extension, Israel, trump loyalty to America and fellow Americans every time. Further, ideology is a lesser concern to the Jews than concern for Jewish economic success and security in a world of inferior non-Jews. The Jews do not care about “black lives.” Black people are there to be used as a vehicle to undermine the Christian values of the majority white population of the U.S. (The Jews are still fighting off the rebel Jesus, just as in the days of The Old Temple, and equally connivingly and cynically. ) Jewish commitment to “social justice” is a mere subterfuge for undermining the inherently Christian nature of the United States. Jews cynically use the Nazi holocaust as a bludgeon against everyone in the world who would criticize the Jews for their behavior. If you are not Jewish, you are responsible for killing 6 million Jews just as much as if you were Hitler himself.

    Finally, I, as a rebellious Jew with a conscience, won’t be spared any more than the clearly demonic Jews who are currently leading the movement to destroy our country (Zuckerberg, Soros, et. al.) For on the day of reckoning, as my mother warned me, all Jews will be treated as one by the Gentiles. If she is right, there is thus no escape for me. But life is fleeting anyway, so I might as well give it my best shot.

  3. A123 says:

    Jewish Leftism is primarily a Reform Branch problem. Voting patterns show this. The Reconstructionist Branch is worse, but also very small.

      

    I have yet to see any good numbers on Conservative Branch votes for Trump 2020. Due to the volume of vote fraud, there may never be reliable numbers from the rigged election. Anecdotal evidence suggest that Trump may have obtained 51%+ of the Conservative vote. However, that still needs to be substantiated.
    __________

    The Left is going to great lengths to become “judenrein”. If pro-Israel SJW’s still exist, they are rare and ostracized. In 2018, the anti-Semitic SJW purge was quite open: (1)

    The unity did not last long. Vanessa Wruble, a Brooklyn-based activist, said she told the group that her Jewish heritage inspired her to try to help repair the world. But she said the conversation took a turn when Tamika Mallory, a black gun control activist, and Carmen Perez, a Latina criminal justice reform activist, replied that Jews needed to confront their own role in racism.

    But the divisions apparent at that very first meeting continue to haunt the Women’s March organization, as charges of anti-Semitism are now roiling the movement and overshadowing plans for more marches next month.

    And, the Left has become even more anti-Semitic since then. The elevation of Rashid Tlaib and Ilhan Omar actively drives Jews out of the Globalist Left DNC.

    The majority of next generation U.S. Jews will have to make a choice to be either Jewish -or- Leftist. A few will no doubt try to be both, but that will be an unenviable life.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/23/us/womens-march-anti-semitism.html

  4. Chris Moore says: • Website

    Finally, I, as a rebellious Jew with a conscience, won’t be spared any more than the clearly demonic Jews who are currently leading the movement to destroy our country (Zuckerberg, Soros, et. al.) For on the day of reckoning, as my mother warned me, all Jews will be treated as one by the Gentiles. If she is right, there is thus no escape for me. But life is fleeting anyway, so I might as well give it my best shot.

    lol. You needn’t worry. Most “Jews” are just method actors carrying out an elaborate and highly profitable psychodrama. They’ll simply change their costumes and identity and take up a similar criminal racket from a different angle.

    The ones who really believed the “We’re descendents of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob” shtick have long since moved to Israel in search of identity validation among like-minded grifter fanatics.

    Your mom was probably indoctrinated into too many goyim boogeyman stories by crusty old conniving rabbis and/or bored radicals looking for something to occupy their minds.

    The “Jews” always did have too much money and not enough common morality.

    • Agree: Jim Christian
    • Thanks: Pheasant
    • Replies: @anon
  5. @Gina Schrank

    I appreciate your efforts, Mr. Joyce, to present an academically fair breakdown of the problem you attack…However, let me please, as a born and raised Jew, break down the problem in much cruder terms. For I fear that in analyzing the “trees” we really do lose sight of the “forest.”

    Thanks for your comment, and while I was reading Mr. Joyce’s article I was thinking something along the same lines. He is very detailed in his assessments and I always appreciate his articles, but all of his “trees” can disorient the goyish mind. Can the core idea that there is something about Jewishness that is a “problem,” as opposed to particular factions of Jews, be presented in a more distilled fashion? Let me try.

    The evidence for a “Jewish Problem” is present in the mere contemporary existence of Jews as a category. What do I mean? I think anyone has to recognize that Jews existing in this day as an identifiable group is a truly remarkable feat. As much as I tend to be a universalist, it is in some ways deserving of awe, if not respect.

    Have you ever met an Etruscan? Ever shared a wine with a native speaker of Latin? Ever had a beer with an Ostrogoth? Ever stared at the stars with a Phoenician? Ever sipped English tea with a Norman? I imagine not. Did these people disappear? Not really. They are still with us, their DNA coursing through our veins after centuries and millennia of assimilation.

    And yet, as all of these identities and categories could not resist becoming part of a greater human alloy, the Jews remain, unique, irreducible like an element on a human periodic table. This accomplishment is even more amazing when you consider that they have been a Diaspora people residing in everybody else’s lands. How did they do it? The simple answer is that they chose to “dwell alone”; comforting themselves generation after generation that they are so divinely special that they must not lower themselves to breaking bread with dogs (gentiles.)

    On the nature vs. nurture debate I am firmly in the nature camp. Genes matter and for personality as much as physical traits. What happens when a narcissistic, exiled, Pharisaic priest class insists on inbreeding generation after generation since time immemorial? Well, you create a bunch of genetic copies of the people who were so arrogant that they had to execute a guy who simply told them to look in the mirror before embarking on some “Tikkun Olam” crusade (it was their one chance to do carpentry and they got Italians to do it for them.) You encode not just high IQ, but narcissism, extreme in-group preference, sociopathy, sadism, machiavellianism, and paranoia along with the Tay Sachs.

    Of course, there are some true universalists born to Jewish parents every generation. But, these kind are soon excommunicated from the Tribe as Self-hating JINOs (Jews in name only) and are pushed into the arms of the gentiles, their children become half-breeds, their grandchildren quadroons and then they are “pure” goy for evermore.

    For on the day of reckoning, as my mother warned me, all Jews will be treated as one by the Gentiles.

    Perhaps what needs to be asked is: who will be “all Jews” on the day of reckoning? Those who have rejected communion with the gentiles who have invited them into their lands. Will they have someone to blame other than themselves?

    • Replies: @Monopduly
  6. unwoke says:

    “Among the more sophisticated, however, in which a definite sense of ethnic interests is foremost, a more nuanced approach emerges, along with a new question altogether: For how long will the politics of my nation turn on the axis of Jewish interests?”

    You certainly don’t have to be very sophisticated to have a sense or greater of ethnic interests, foremost or less. And the question of how long will the politics of “my” nation turn on the axis of Jewish interests is hardly a new one, as the article itself alludes earlier. But you can’t even ask such questions publicly & if you can’t pose a question, you won’t get an answer. Jewish power now is much more insidious than ever. Even high-profile SJW’s like Omar have been forced to retreat in the face of it, as when she candidly talked about the relationship between politicians & The Lobby as being “all about the Benjamins” & was forced to apologize. Another member of ‘the squad’, Rep. Pressley voted in favor of a motion in congress against the Israel boycott & divestment movement. And then on the other side, you have those like Gov. Abbott of TX making false accusations of “anti-semitism” against alternative social media platform Gab. It’s not just left & right Jews who are united behind Jewish interests at home & abroad, but more frustratingly, left & right politicians in America. The one thing Biden & Trump agreed on was their loyalty to unconstrained Israel & its supporters here at home. And sadly, there’s not much indication that the politics of our nation will NOT continue to turn on the “axis” of Jewish interests far into the future.

    • Replies: @Mulga Mumblebrain
  7. 36 ulster says:
    @Gina Schrank

    If there is to be a day of reckoning, I believe that it will be far in the future–if it ever arrives. We’ve had almost sixty years of “civil rights” and “social justice,” yet many of us stubbornly cling to the concepts of individual freedom and liberty. Even our non-revolutionary, United-Empire-Loyalist neighbors above the 49th Parallel embrace these concepts, though these are being severely tested by the current regime and its malignant bureaucracies. As someone who regards his “community” utterly without self-congratulation or sentimentality, I appreciate your ability to cast a withering stare at your own. I’m not optimistic about defeating the globo-homo-anarcho-tyranno entente, but win or lose, if you choose to leave our–your–country, you needn’t be compelled to: With scores of millions of illegal aliens in the country, we obviously don’t do mass deportations and repatriations very well.

    • Replies: @anarchyst
  8. LarryS says:

    Can a Christian be an atheist?
    Can a Judean be an atheist? Apparently.
    For some reason I can’t find Pharisees or rabbis in the Old Testament.
    I really doubt there are any physical descendants of Jacob alive today.
    The “Jews” of today are descendants of converts from long ago.

    Also, the modern, secular state called Israel should really be called Judea.
    The Kingdom of Israel (10 tribes) ended forever in about 722BC.

    • Replies: @noname27
    , @Realist
    , @moi
  9. FvS says:

    This CJV vs. ADL spat is a classic example of Jewish mitosis a.k.a. the Esau Gambit, a tactic commonly used when the goyim start noticing too much.

    • Agree: profnasty
  10. JimDandy says:
    @Gina Schrank

    There is no day of reckoning coming from white (formerly) Christian cultures. The greatest possibility of something like a day of reckoning is a world war catastrophe caused by Neocon Zionists who just can’t seem to stop themselves from pushing things too far. If that happens, Jews and Gentiles will face the same fate.

    • Disagree: Robert Dolan
    • Replies: @Robert Dolan
  11. KenR says:
    @Gina Schrank

    You can stop being a Jew. If you come over to Jesus, you stop being a Jew. Of course, you will be spurned by the Jews, and your open invitation to emigrate to Israel will be rescinded (they know). You can free yourself from the shackles of Judaism.

  12. anon[362] • Disclaimer says:
    @Chris Moore

    Crusty old conniving Rabbis? Like the blasphemous Rabbi Jesus who stated “Salvation is from the Jews?”

    Always had too much money? Is the Jewish author of the Jew Testament passage Romans 15:27 wrong when he writes that the “Goyim (Gentiles) owe it $$$ to the Jews?”

  13. gotmituns says:

    Is Jewish Leftism a ‘Reform Problem’?
    ————————————————-
    There is no leftism or reform of jewry. Jews are jews and that ‘s the end of discussion. If you want a word for them it’s, parasite.

  14. @A123

    No Jew can, I believe, be dedicated to justice, while being a Zionist. Many Jews have made the move away from Zionism, a racist, supremacist, terrorist cult, and more power to them. Zionism is for the Jews as Nazism was for Germans, Hindutva is for Hindu Indians, and so on. And no Talmudist Jew can be anything but an enemy of humanity as long as they believe that their tribe is a superior species to the goyim.

  15. Dumbo says:
    @Gina Schrank

    Why don’t Jews just (sincerely) convert to Christianity? Problem solved.

    Lots of Gentiles descend from sincerely converted Jews.

    No gentile persecutes sincerely converted Jews (the Inquisition was about those who only fake-converted). Even Hitler had Jews in his army. Maybe even Hitler was partially Jewish. Torquemada was Jewish.

    Ok, ok, I understand about Jews wanting to keep their tradition and their uniqueness, perhaps they are interesting in their own unique way, I like some Jewish writers and perhaps their outlook comes from their uniqueness – but on the other hand, it has been creating trouble to everyone and to themselves for ages. If they can’t assimilate, then they could try to live by themselves, not among a majority they hate or who hates them. I thought that was the idea behind the creation of Israel?

  16. noname27 says: • Website
    @Chris Moore

    Neoliberalism is Stalinism, and neoconservatism is Trotskyism.

  17. noname27 says: • Website
    @LarryS

    Oh how wrong you are:

    White Caucasians are The True Israelites – God’s Chosen Race (NOT JEWS). They were placed in the Caucasus region circa 725 BC by the Assyrians (forefathers of the Germans) when Assyria invaded the Northern Kingdom of Israel and took them away as captives. From there they migrated west into Europe – the rest is history.

    OUR ANCESTORS FORGOT WHO WE ARE!!!!!!!

    Here are the ‘Lost’ Tribes or The Twelve Tribes of Israel:

    [MORE]

    These are Jacob/Israel’s Twelve Sons who were or became The Twelve Patriarchs and progenitors of twelve clans that became 12 modern western nations.

    Joseph, whom Jacob loved, represented by Joseph’s two sons Ephraim and Manasseh – the Birthright Inheritors,

    Benjamin the youngest son,

    Simeon,

    Levi – The Priesthood,

    Judah – The Royal Sceptre to Yashua Messiah, King David, British Royalty and Nobility,

    Reuben – the eldest son who, like Esau, lost the Birthright Inheritance,

    Issachar,

    Zeebulon,

    Gad,

    Asher,

    Dan,

    Naphtali.

    Joseph = Ephraim = Anglo-Saxon England (The Saacae or Saaka – Isaac’s sons = Saxons) and Her Anglo-Saxon Commonwealth – Australia, Canada, NZ and S Africa (Now stolen).

    Joseph = Manasseh = Anglo-Saxon USA (The Saacae or Saaka – Isaac’s sons = Saxons)

    Simeon = Scotland (The Scythians) and Scottish descendants everywhere.

    Levi = Wales, (The Druids = descendants of The Levitical Priesthood with many butchered by the Romans in 46 AD) Cornwall and The Walloons of Belgium and Welsh descendants everywhere.

    Judah (The Jutes not the Jews) = Northern Ireland (The Red Hand Flag of Zarah), Scotland and some dispersed in England with some also still dispersed in Western Europe including Germany (Assyria).

    Benjamin = Norway, Iceland and Denmark.

    Dan = (The Tuatha de Danaan) Southern Ireland and Irish descendants everywhere.

    Reuben = Northern Gallic France = Paris, Brittany and Normandy and Gallic French descendants everywhere.

    Zebulon pronounced Zeebulon – a haven for ships = Holland (the Zuider Zee) and Dutch descendants everywhere.

    Gad = Flanders (modern Belgium) including The Walloons.

    Issachar = Switzerland.

    Naphtali = Finland.

    Asher = Sweden and Swedish descendants everywhere.

    13 tribes listed in all due to Joseph’s two sons Ephraim & Manasseh both inheriting.

    “…there are but two tribes in Asia and Europe subject to the Romans, while The Ten Tribes are beyond (the river) Euphrates (South of the Caucasus mountains) till now, and are an immense multitude, and not to be estimated by numbers.”

    — Flavius Josephus

    Try and apply this verse to the Jews – God’s promise to Abraham:

    Genesis 13:16 (MCV) *And I will make thy seed as the dust of the earth: so that if a man can number the dust of the earth, then shall thy seed also be numbered.*

    From the Declaration of Arbroath to Pope John XXII 1320 AD:

    “Most Holy Father and Lord, we know and from the chronicles and books of the ancients we find that among other famous nations our own, the Scots, has been graced with widespread renown. They journeyed from Greater Scythia by way of the Tyrrhenian Sea and the Pillars of Hercules, and dwelt for a long course of time in Spain among the most savage tribes, but nowhere could they be subdued by any race, however barbarous. Thence they came, twelve hundred years after the people of Israel crossed the Red Sea, to their home in the west where they still live today.”

    Daniel 9:7 (KJV) O Lord, righteousness belongeth unto thee, but unto us confusion of faces, as at this day; to the men of Judah, and to the inhabitants of Jerusalem, and unto all Israel, that are near, and that are far off, through all the countries whither thou hast driven them, because of their trespass that they have trespassed against thee.

    Britain consists of five of the Twelve Tribes of Israel – Ephraim = England; Simeon = Scotland; Wales and Cornwall = Levi; Judah = Northern Ireland and Scotland; Dan = Southern Ireland.

    The British Gaelic and Old English tongues are Hebrew in origin, this has been proven by linguistic scholars.

    Saynt Hierome also translated the Bible into his mother tongue [that is, the Latin Vulgate]. “Why maye not we also? They wyll saye, it can not be translated in to our tongue, it is so rude. It is not so rude as they are false lyers. For the Greke tongue agreeth more with the englyshe, than with the latyne.”

    “In the case of Hebrew, scholars have noted that Tyndale was right in sensing the superiority of English to Latin in matters of rendering Hebrew syntax. One scholar has noted that Hebrew and English have similar word orders and that in his English translation, Tyndale masterfully rendered the syntax of the original Hebrew into a fluid and rhythmical English prose that in turn influenced English writers.”

    — Religious Studies Centre

    “The English tongue agreeth with the Hebrew a thousand times more than with the Latin.”

    – William Tyndale – multi-linguist and early translator of the English Bible.

    The Saaca or Saacea (Isaac’s sons = saxons) came from the lands of the Medes and Parthians where the Assyrians (Germans) placed them after taking the Northern Kingdom of Israel captive in 725 BC.

    The Scythians (The tribe of Simeon – The Scots) came from the same area between the Caspian Sea and Black Sea and north of the Black Sea.

    Sir Francis Drake and Elizabeth I both knew England was Israel – privately QE II also knows.

    Joshua 1:3 (KJV) Every place that the sole of your foot shall tread upon, that have I given unto you, as I said unto Moses.

    The Mayflower American founding fathers (the Puritans) all knew that England was Israel and planted Israel in the promised land of the New World – New England.

    The word British is from the Hebrew words ‘Berith’ and ‘Ish’. Hebrew Berith = Covenant and Hebrew Ish = man so British means Covenant Man.

    Engl-land again is from the Hebrew word ‘igl’ which means bullock. England = Bullock-land. Ephraim was known as God’s young bullock, the firstlings, and his fair child.

    Deuteronomy 33:17 (KJV) His glory is like the firstling of his bullock, and his horns are like the horns of unicorns: with them he shall push the people together to the ends of the earth: and they are the ten thousands of Ephraim, and they are the thousands of Manasseh.

    Ireland was originally known as Ebernia from Abraham’s forefather Eber from whence comes the Hebrew tongue and the race collectively known as the Hebrews – Eber’s descendants.

    The Iberian peninsular also gets its name from Eber. These places were named by Zarah in his migrations who was the twin brother of Pharez who were Judah’s two sons by Tamar – Saragossa in Spain takes its name from Zarah who had the red thread tied to his wrist at the time of his birth – the Zarah Red Hand of Northern Ireland and on its flag to this day.

    The Hebrides off the west of Scotland are really the Hebrew-des.

    The Scots and Irish both play the bagpipes which are known to have Middle Eastern origins.

    The first Christian churches planted outside of Jerusalem were in Britain in 35 AC and there is archaeological evidence to prove it. These churches were planted by Joseph of Arimathea and his small band of saints. This proves the Israelites were in Britain. British churches pre-date Antioch.

    “The apostles passed beyond the ocean to the isles called the Britannic Isles.”

    — Eusebius circa 260-340 AC ( Demonstratio Evangelica or Proof of the Gospel , book 3, chap. 7)

    “We certainly know that Christ, the true Son, afforded His light, the knowledge of His precepts, to our Island in the last year of Tiberius Caesar” (Tiberius died in 37 AC)

    — Gildas the Wise, circa 550 AC (De Excidio Britanniae or On the Ruin of Britain )

    Caucasians = White Israelites, White Caucasians are The True Israelites (NOT JEWS). They were placed in the Caucasus region circa 725 BC by the Assyrians (forefathers of the Germans) when Assyria invaded the Northern Kingdom of Israel and took them away as captives. From there they migrated west into Europe – the rest is history.

    The ‘Lost’ Tribes of Israel:
    https://worldtruthvideos.org/watch/the-true-israelites-are-white-europeans-jews-admit-it-blacks-deny-and-hate-it_YV623JNaZ7Gy5IK.html

    • Agree: profnasty
    • Thanks: Arthur MacBride, G J T
    • LOL: Alden
    • Replies: @Rev. Spooner
    , @Anon
    , @hillaire
  18. Cohen says:
    @A123

    Nice to see you back. How are little Talmudist doing.
    I am sorry to see 55 or so individuals died in Israel while celebrating something.

    Any house grabbing from Palestinians lately. How is human organ trades coming along? I am trying hard to learn Talmud. A lot of contradiction.
    What kind of Citizenship do you have in Israel. Platinum (Zionist), Gold (just regular Jews) and Basic (can it be upgraded) for Black Jews and Arab Jews. You guys are great.

    • LOL: A123
    • Replies: @Alden
  19. Jewish right: Die for Israel, pay money to Israel, democrats are the real racists, more scab labor to grow the GDP, 50 more holocaust statues and ”testing our resolve” against Russia, China and Iran.

    Jewish left: Anal marriage, child mutilation, negro worship, digital prostitution, refugees welcome, Richard the Lionheart was Black and we need to invade Russia and China in order to bring the joys of blacked pornography and drag queen story hour.

    Its essentially the choice between taking cyanide and nightshade.

    I back the centrist option.

    Destroy Israel and expel every last Jew from all nations and quarantine them all in Madagascar. There they can have all the diversity and gay butt pride they want

  20. Jake says:
    @Chris Moore

    Neoconservatism in the English-speaking world is, significantly, Trotskyism as opposed to Stalinism. But it also is old time Anglo imperialist Capitalism, with the stress on Jewish financiers of WASP empire.

  21. Cohen says:

    Hey 123. You did not remove the peace emoji yet. You really love peace?
    Why you guys hate Christians and to a lessor degree Muslims. Help me

    A while back you proudly put some Palestinian constitution where it states that selling land to peace loving Jew is punishable by death. I did not know Palestinians have a constitution??/ While caged, ruled, occupied by Israel. It was also in your national newspaper The JEWYOK TIMES

    I wish there could be an international law against selling anything to Zionists. Jews are OK.
    BTW. Can you please send me a copy of Israeli borders. I know Doctors without borders or Journalist without border. But never, “Israelis without borders” Still searching for their home land.
    How the planning to destroy Al-Aqsa mosque is coming along. Any date set yet. I hope to make some money buying some options in important corporations. Call or Puts does not matter. Have a peaceful day.

    • LOL: A123
    • Replies: @A123
  22. @Gina Schrank

    Brave, honourable woman. I wish you well.

    • Agree: Niebelheim
  23. Jake says:
    @Chris Moore

    The solution, such as it can be on this earth, is Christ and Christendom. Those of Jewish ancestry who continue to choose to be Jews will still do their damnedest to cause trouble, but a society embracing Christendom negates and neuters Jewish revolutionary activities. Every society that begins to step away from Christ and Christendom guarantees that increasing numbers of Jews will show act to pervert and then invert what once had been a nation proud to be part of Christendom.

    There is no other option that can ever even ameliorate the problem.

  24. @Dumbo

    Yes, Erhard Milch was arguably one of the most powerful figures in the Luftwaffe despite being Jewish. Even Goering and Messerschmidt regularly deferred to him.

  25. Jake says:
    @Gina Schrank

    For on the day of reckoning, as my mother warned me, all Jews will be treated as one by the Gentiles.

    I assume that your ,other means by ‘day of reckoning’ the time when the non-Jews of a land realize that a small number of Jews have done horrors to their country and people?

    The actuality is the people in all the world who are least likely to act as your mother asserts (blame and then act to harm all of a people for the horrid sins of its , say, worst 50%) are whites whose national/ethnic cultures are defined by a millennium or more of Christian tradition.

    Jews acting to destroy white Christian nations and identities are actually arranging for a world in which non-white non-Christians will have no stay on their hands when they decide to try to exterminate the Jewish race.

    Satan always has such fun with those who serve anti-Christ bellies, hearts, and minds.

  26. profnasty says:
    @Chris Moore

    So FKN tired of “ism’s”.
    Can we go back to “ist’s”?

  27. The whole Tucker Carlson thing with the ADL and the rabbis reminded me of the meme “shut it down, the goynim know.” The real problem is how many gentiles want a Jew approval before they speak out. True liberation begins when you don’t.

    • Agree: ChuckOrloski
    • Replies: @anarchyst
  28. geokat62 says:

    … can only gain traction among those whose worldview is simplistic and without nuance, and who perceive all of contemporary politics under the basic rubric of Left versus Right.

    There are, unfortunately, quite a few Unzers who fall for this deception.

  29. Jerster says:

    Joyce never disagrees with himself. He has a theory all about Jews and no matter what the facts are the theory always explains everything.

    So when there are real right-wing Jews who are right-wing not for what’s good for the Jews, but for what’s good for extremely right-wing people, he cannot accept that. Joyce reminds me of an academic leftist; the conclusion is always there and you just fit the data into it. Any Jew who is right wing must be pretending because they think it’s good for the Jews. Because each and very person of some particular ethnic extraction thinks exactly the same way as every other person from that group. It’s science!

    This is truly lowbrow stuff. I understand the constant striving towards an academic position you won’t ever get, but you lack the most important thing a good academic needs – an open mind. Why don’t you think about this sometime: is it possible for you to write a column that your readers won’t know the conclusion to before they’ve even read it?

    • LOL: Che Guava
    • Replies: @geokat62
  30. saggy says:

    I think it’s an appropriate time to tackle the subject directly

    .
    Once the issue is settled, I hope you’ll turn your attention to yet another controversial issue, I’m thinking of the perplexing question, “Is the moon really made of green cheese?”

  31. @Gina Schrank

    Don’t worry,blacks are going to fix everything. blacks are the REAL joooos,so says the Hoteps. blacks are F’in geniuses.They built everything ,everywhere. blacks are everybody.Everyone is black. Native Americans,Chinese,Japanese,Russians,Koreans,Tibetans,Puerto Ricans ,Mexicans, etc.etc..We Wuz Everybody. So since we are all black WEREZZ MY REPRATIONZZZ and sheit.

    • Replies: @Marckus
  32. … the Jewish participants attempted to rhetorically carve off elements of the Jewish population, scapegoating them temporarily in order that broader Jewish goals (social, political, or economic) might be achieved …

    Indeed this plus multiple other shape-shifting tactics remains the situation today as Jews like Gina Schrank (thanks, Gina) testify and anybody with a working brain knows.

    It remains a grotesque parody that the ADL (founded to defend a Jewish pedophile murderer) can loudly condemn a journalist for journalistic activity, make strident “demands” on his employer. Especially given Jewish-provoked bloodbaths of C20, their role in destroying America & “the west”, events like JFK, 9/11, missing Pentagon trillions, Fed, corporate raiders, Palestine etc etc.

    However they could never have done any of these things and got away scot-free without active Gentile help from politicians/State apparatchiks, “journalists”, zio-“christians” etc, plus almost universal passive help from millions who can’t be bothered or who are too stupid/slothful from years of talmudvision. Freemasonry. Corrupt rulers. “Court historians”. The low-grade dolts who pile into Mr Adelson’s casino etc.

  33. anarchyst says:
    @36 ulster

    Your statement: /We’ve had almost sixty years of “civil rights” and “social justice,” yet many of us stubbornly cling to the concepts of individual freedom and liberty./…is starting to crack. Actually, “individual freedom” should serve to negate forced “public accommodation” laws and should result in the restoration of “freedom of association” for all, not just for “people of color”. Yes, this includes us whites as well.

    Blacks who benefited the most from the so-called “civil-rights (for some)” and “affirmative action” laws (that really disenfranchised only whites) are starting to demand the very same things that us whites were forced to “give up” with the adoption of the misguided and destructive “civil-rights (for some)” laws. True “freedom of association” was made illegal, being replaced with government-backed and forced “public accommodation” laws and statutes.

    “People of color” are demanding segregated “safe spaces and self-segregation…something that would have been unheard of, only ten years ago.

    When I hear well-meaning whites protesting against “people of color” who are demanding voluntary, non-government imposed segregation, I think to myself “what the hell is wrong with you?” This benefits not only “people of color”, but us whites as well. Finally, us whites could be advised of where we are not welcome.

    The whole “civil-rights (for some)” scam denies one basic aspect of human nature–the right to freely associate with like-minded people of the same race and culture and the right to exclude those NOT of the same race and culture.

    It is long overdue to jettison the whole “civil-rights (for some)” scam and restore real freedom across the board.

  34. geokat62 says:
    @Jerster

    Why don’t you think about this sometime: is it possible for you to write a column that your readers won’t know the conclusion to before they’ve even read it?

    Why don’t you put this same challenge to the leading members of the over 600 Jewish Supremacist Organizations (the ADL, SPLAC, AIPAC, AJC, etc etc etc etc etc) in America? I’m confident they’ll meet your “open mind” test.

    • Agree: ChuckOrloski
    • Replies: @Jerster
  35. anarchyst says:
    @Old and Grumpy

    The ADL needs to be exposed for what it is–an organization formed to protect criminal jews from scrutiny and prosecution for crimes that they commit.
    Starting out with serial rapist jew Leo Frank who raped and murdered Mary Phagan, a thirteen-year old employee of his, while attempting to “pin” the crime on a black man. In those days, it would have been easy for Frank to get away with his crimes; a black man would have been easy to prosecute. Fortunately the justice system of the day worked.
    Despite attempts to “purchase” a pardon, (which was in the works due to influential jews getting involved in the process), the local townspeople decided to exact true justice on Frank, giving him a well-deserved “necktie party”.
    The ADL was formed as a result…being a criminal organization formed solely to protect criminal jews.

  36. There seems a simple fraud at the heart of this matter! Jews are white people…none more so than they are. despite white anti-semitism, the fact that Jews are indeed white must have played a huge part in Jewish success over a millennia.

    The Jews are included in the white power structure because they are indeed white and are in no way misfits in the overall elitist white program in the world. they are in fact the greatest facilitators of that program

    The current Jewish people have no blood connection to the original Jews who were Black people; apparently Moorish or very mixed by the time of their disappearance. Current Jews, Russians who converted are white people, imperial of nature from their beginnings, never changed, facilitated the expansion of Europe into world domination, underpinned the rise of the vast wealth and power of European elites… a global wealth and power that the Jews themselves have now fully appropriated

  37. Okay, either I’m getting too old (probably true), or this guy can’t write. Compare:

    In regards to the first element, the ‘limits’ of Jewish involvement, there are few, if any, anti-Jewish theories in circulation which ascribe to Jews sole responsibility for the entirety of contemporary leftist activism.

    to: “Nobody says every angry street protester is a Jew.”

    They both get to the same point, but one requires parsing while the other slaps you in the face.

    One of Ron Unz’s best qualities is his ability to distill complex subject matter into simple declarative sentences, which makes the entire American Pravda series so accessible.

    Too much polysyllabic pedantry obscures the forest for the trees. Disappointing.

    • Replies: @Realist
  38. Realist says:

    Kudos to Carlson for his defense of Whites against anti-White racism. Hopefully, he will step up his efforts by using the term anti-white racism and calling out those who promote it. He could spend many segments doing a thorough evaluation of such.

  39. Marckus says:
    @dindunuffins

    There are some misguided Afro souls on this thread who assert “white Jews” are not the real Jews but that the real Jews were black. Jesus was black, God was black and now we got black Jews. The next thing is a black Pope in the Vatican LOL.

    The only black Jew I know of was Sammy Davis. He had to do a lot of knob gobbling or his musical career was done. In the end the poor little dwarf did not pray enough to his God (or did not donate enough to the local Synagogue) and had one eye plucked out.

    I can also prove, without leaving the comfort of my coffee cup, that there are no black jews. How ? Are there black people living in Israel ?

    • Replies: @dindunuffins
    , @Hossein
  40. Realist says:
    @Nancy Pelosi's Latina Maid

    One of Ron Unz’s best qualities is his ability to distill complex subject matter into simple declarative sentences, which makes the entire American Pravda series so accessible.

    Few are as prolix as Ron Unz.

  41. Richard B says:
    @Chris Moore

    Are “progressive” Judeofascists the problem, and “conservative” Judeofascists the solution? Was ((neoconservatism)) the solution to ((Bolshevism))?

    Excellent point Chris. Because, if I understand you correctly, it’s a quesiton of Jews solving problems among themselves in front of us. Almost as if we’re not there, though we’re clearly the target. Or, perhaps a better word would be the mark.

    Their goal Jewish Supremacy – Full Spectrum Dominance does not change – ever. It’s not for nothing they call themselves the Chosen people. Doesn’t get more ethnocentric, to use a word they liked to use against Whites during the 20th century.

    The terminology since then has, like the cultures they produce and the countries they ruin, cruder, more blatant, coarse, and Orwellian, but not the point of it all, which is to serve their ultimate goal of Jewish Supremacy – Full Spectrum Dominance.

    From Andrew’s article:

    The fundamental goal of these rhetorical strategies was to defuse and weaken the anti-Semitic reaction, with both Mendelssohn and Marx keen to ease the Jewish path to full civic equality in Europe.

    But it’s never been about equalityever.

    It’s been about Jewish Supremacy – Full Spectrum Dominance.

    Or, as a Jewish friend of mine once said back in the 80’s after attending a lecture given by the Israeli statesman Abba Eban, “Israel, a democracy? How can anything Jewish be democratic?

    Though I don’t always agree with the writers over at TOO it’s impossible, for me at least, not to admire them greatly. I feel the same way about Ron Unz for that matter. Speaking for myself, though I know I’m not alone in this, I’m very grateful for their work.

    But, once you’ve identified the problem (or, one aspect of it at least), once you’ve gathered a reasonable amount of data, once you’ve adquately evaluated the problem, the next obvious step is to propose concrete, workable solutions.

    In that regard, however, and unfortunately, even Andrew Joyce has himself admitted in a previous article that he doesn’t know the answer to the problem. And that itself is a problem. One that we can rest assured Jewish Supremacy Inc. will take full advantage of.

    Then again, it’s not like they’ll have to work too hard. Since the pushback is, at this point, entirely verbal, and that verbal behavior is mostly written, not spoken. Certainly not spoken publicly.

    It’s only until the pushback becomes, well, non-verbal, that things will get really interesting. But does anyone see that happening any time soon?

    Until then, and as long as we’re limited to the written word, Andrew Joyce ends his excellent essay (has he ever written a bad one?) with a great question:

    For how long will the politics of my nation turn on the axis of Jewish interests?

    This helps direct attention to something even more important than any single nation, the question of biological adaptation. The question now becomes this:

    Is Jewish Supremacy Inc.‘s Full Spectrum Dominance reducing the human race to the status of a biologically maladaptive species?

    I think the obvious answer is, It very well may be. Why?

    Because adaptability depends entirely on the organisms ability to not only respond, but to respond competently to the many problems it faces.

    But with JSI running the show, we’re not allowed to respond to anything they don’t want us to if it means challenging their power, even if that power is destroying our ability to respond to our many problems, problems that will eventually include them, of course!

    It is no small thing that this is happening at a time when the civilization they now control is more complex and unpredictable than ever before in human history. Unable to respond, we can’t adapt. Hence the reduction of the human race to the status of a biologically maladaptive species.

    We’re not even allowed to identify our problems (or, the problem) let alone solve them.

    In any event, as long as the range of response is limited to the verbal, this might be the next point in which to direct the conversation. Simply because there is no greater problem than being rendered a maladaptive species.

    Maybe in the end this is what is meant by being Chosen, ie; Chosen to reduce the entire human race to the status of a biologically maladaptive species. Again, it very well may be. This would certainly make the Susan Sontag quote about Whites being the cancer of the human race yet another example of Jewish projection. Either way, the quesiton still stands.

    • Thanks: Robjil
    • Replies: @Chris Moore
  42. @Jake

    …but a society embracing Christendom negates and neuters Jewish revolutionary activities.

    Two things are required for this great and necessary benefit to occur:

    1) the solidarity of the Roman Catholic Church, the only human force in history which has a track record of subduing Jew perfidy because absent such an all-encompassing authority over the population Divinely inspired by Christ Jesus the instinctively concerted efforts of the Jew termites to relentlessly eat away at the at the morals and cultural structure of ordered civilization overwhelms through Jew use of armies of available shabat goyim foot soldiers motivated as hirelings and/or dupes; and

    2) explicitly identifying the evil meaning #nameTheJew as the offspring of (((their))) forefather the devil as Jesus did at John 8:44.

  43. Cohen says:
    @A123

    I believe we should revisit and upgrade General Grant’s executive order to expel cotton trade profiteers (guess who, the Jews) from Tennessee with in 24 hours. And they complied like a charm in December 1862. Let us revise that law and implement in New York, Washington, DC, and California first. After all they wanted a homeland. Send them to Israel with one way ticket.

    Please note I did not use the word black market (as mentioned in his order) to upset Oprah, Al Sharpton and Civil right “icon” Black Andrew young.

    Hey 123 how do your Zionist brothers feel about General Grant. Can we call him Antisemitic and put his picture in New York City Buses with the word Anti Semite. You guys are expert in this field. As you guys, a while back, put a guy named Grand Mufti picture with Hitler in New York buses using first Amendment. May be I should start gofund movement to collect money for this act of the General Grant, a civil war hero as anti semite. Would you and your friend chip in a few bucks. After all it is for good cause.

    Where are ADL. AIPAC JDL and others when we need them. Peace and real peace.

  44. Terrorist Ziocorporate globalism rules its conglomerate of US/NATO terrorist regimes with more sophistication than that. Idiots are still quite lost in the intrigues of left-right political bullshit.

    Even the terrorist Ziojew invaders are nothing more than disposable pawns, if they weren’t they wouldn’t bred and grown with “Holocaust” fantasy indoctrination so they’re more traumatised/fit to go kill and terrorise Palestinians in the British empire’s Rothschild neocolony, or be killed when fighting slightly competent and armed rivals like Hezbollah.

    Europeans had fought thousands of battles against each other for centuries, since Crusader times, before Jews were given the notorious position they’ve had since the late 1800s, so the Left vs Right fake Western “democracy” and its conflicts are a mere political continuation of what used to be feudal militancy that Ziocorporate power has taken advantage of, seeing that most people are just as stupid and easily manipulated as back when they way vassals paying tribute to their feudal lords, bishops and kings in the 1300s.

    And while Jews occupy the egregious position they do in their neo-Crusader statelet and Western “left-right” elites, who audits the Fed, ECB, Vatican bank (and, why not, the “reformed” churches) and City of London?

  45. Realist says:
    @LarryS

    Can a Christian be an atheist?
    Can a Judean be an atheist?

    No, the questions are non sequiturs.

  46. HdC says:
    @Gina Schrank

    As long as you subscribe to the Six Million stick and propagate it, you have a long way to go to be considered a rebellious Jew.

    After all, the Holy Six Million are the underlying thesis of modern Judaism, with nary a bit of hard evidence. And if you quote so-called eye witnesses or the Nuernberg trials, you are even further from what you claim to be or aspire to be.

    Perhaps if you could supply forensic or other scientific evidence to support that thesis, you’d be much closer to being that rebellious Jew.

    Of course, if you cannot find any such evidence then, wanting to be rebellious, you’d have to shout your findings, or rather the lack thereof, from the roof tops. But, you are not THAT rebellious, are you?

    • Replies: @dindunuffins
  47. HT says:

    Jewish Leftism? We used to call it communism. The reality is communism is one thing that cannot be allowed in a free country because eventually, if it is not eliminated, it could result in freedom being removed. The wealthy Jews that now run all of our institutions are working feverishly to destroy our liberty and even our race. How long do you wait before you fight back?

  48. @Caspar Von Everec

    Excellent assessment.
    Once we have isolated and disempowered tbe Jews then we go after all the FreeMason(=satanists).
    There will be blood regardless.
    To me, it makes more sense that it be their blood than ours. After all, we aren’t the evil child rapists and blood sacrificers are we?

  49. “For how long will the politics of my nation turn on the axis of Jewish interests?”

    Unless and until they are confronted head on…

  50. @JimDandy

    A day of reckoning will come for sure.

    Most men would rather die on their feet than live on their knees.

    The nose does NOT have our consent to rule over us, and there is no way that tyranny can be sustained.

    • Replies: @JimDandy
    , @dindunuffins
  51. The very continued existence of Israel is in the long run highly subversive to Jewish advocacy of multiculturalism. Now the the Jews have a land of their own, there is a motive for Jewish participation in intellectual rationalization for “blood and soil” politics.

    A bit of evidence that this may manifest is Yoram Hazony and his book “The Virtue of Nationalism” and the attempt to make a political philosophy or movement out of “National Conservatism”.

  52. @Marckus

    Wait…I love coffee….I take mine BLACK!!!! ! adding WHITE milk is RAYCISSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!! lmfao!

  53. @Jake

    I look around and see Christiandom in ruins, the traditional Christian churches, adorned with the political flags of modernity, empty and indifferent to the fate of their former congregants’ descendants, the clergy as weak, useless sycophants who would betray their flocks to the wolves in a heartbeat rather than be called anti-Semitic in public by a single Jew, and Christianity itself offering nothing but assistance to the Zionist project. And your argument is that we need more of that?

    • Replies: @G J T
  54. @HdC

    Here THIS IS the GREATEST …EXPLAINS IT ALLLLLLLLL!!!! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WjbsD-TYi3s

  55. The problem is not a Jewish problem it is a zionist problem, see the book The Controversy of Zion by Douglas Reed, it can be had on amazon.

    The zionists have hijacked the Jews and led them into communism and destruction,all via the zionist central banks, which are one of the 10 planks of the communist manifesto.

    Many Jews opposed zionism and their barbaric ways including Albert Einstein.

    • Replies: @JM
  56. Jews cannot and should not be trusted by Whites at all. As a people, a race, they are not Whites, and they have been the devoted enemies of Whites for centuries. They are always a parasitic drag, and are unprincipled liars, cheaters and thieves.
    And worse, radical Leftist tyranny is a Jewish invention that huge numbers of Jews automatically accept as a weapon against Whites.
    Part of Leftist tyranny was codified by the Frankfort Group in which the destruction of White civilization was deemed necessary.
    Negro worship is a Jewish invention in which the ugliest, stupidest, most violent, most immoral, most parasitic race is held up to morally-superior promethean heroes. Only these savages can redeem Whites and “save us” from ourselves.
    We don’t need Jews (or other nonWhites). They have declared themselves our enemies. Some of them will attempt to ride White Nationalism for their own gain; again as parasites.

    • Replies: @ben sampson
  57. G J T says:

    I enjoy reading Mr. Joyce’s work. He is an eloquent writer and easily one of the most well-informed commentators on the Jewish problem out there.

    I just can’t help but think we’ve moved into the phase where the purely academic approach has outlived its usefulness. The vast majority of the people we need to reach don’t have the patience or the proper historical reference points to read and absorb these types of analyses. I know of the many individuals in my personal sphere who are somewhere on the scale of being a dissident without being all the way there, none of them are going to read these kinds of articles if I pass them along. Society as a whole is no longer receptive to a truly methodical and scientific approach to anything, the only notable exceptions being the type of people who frequently comment on this site.

    I suppose the hope is that there will be a point in the future where, having been preserved by those of us who tried to resist this global regime, the great work of men like Joyce can be looked back on as validation of our cause and proof of its righteousness. My instinct tells me, however, this is not likely.

    With very few exceptions, a Jew is a Jew is a Jew is a Jew. The distinctions between them personally, just like the distinctions in the totally fabricated political system they’ve created, are superficial and intended primarily for consumption of the goyim and the furthering of Jewish collective interests. They are shapeshifters whose morality (if you can call it that) is utterly foreign to the rest of us. To think it’s any more complicated than that is to totally miss the point and have no historical perspective other than what Jews themselves have constructed for you.

  58. Alden says:
    @Cohen

    This week’s riots are about the eviction of Palestinian families from one of the few remaining Palestinian neighborhoods in Jerusalem so Jewish conquerors can move in. No compensation of course.

  59. Chris Moore says: • Website
    @Richard B

    Maybe in the end this is what is meant by being Chosen, ie; Chosen to reduce the entire human race to the status of a biologically maladaptive species. Again, it very well may be. This would certainly make the Susan Sontag quote about Whites being the cancer of the human race yet another example of Jewish projection. Either way, the quesiton still stands.

    But, once you’ve identified the problem (or, one aspect of it at least), once you’ve gathered a reasonable amount of data, once you’ve adquately evaluated the problem, the next obvious step is to propose concrete, workable solutions.

    What is the solution to cancer? There is no single solution, but there’s mitigation, there’s removal, there’s radiation…

    Clearly, the Jew-stooge remedy of letting it run wild is destroying the patient. Maybe removal of the Jew-stooge, far-left to far-right, is part of the answer.

  60. A123 says:
    @Cohen

    Cohen of Islam,

    I am a Protestant Christian who believes in PEACE.

    You bizarre rambling is very funny. You demonstrate the illiteracy and irrationality we have come to expect from the non-Palestinian Muslim Occupiers in Judea and Samaria.

    Why don’t you take your non-indigenous faith, and return home to Qom (or Tehran)? Your non-Palestinian people will be much happier when they stop occupying land that belongs to Palestinian Christians and Palestinian Jews.

    PEACE 😇

  61. noname27 says: • Website
    @Rev. Spooner

    Prove it!

    You can start by showing me the word ‘Jew’ in the first 11 books of The Bible. When you have failed to do that you can then apply these Holy Scriptures to the Jews:

    Genesis 48:8-20 And Jacob/Israel beheld Joseph’s sons, and said, Who are these?

    [MORE]

    9 And Joseph said unto his father, They are my sons, whom God hath given me in this place (Egypt). And he said, Bring them, I pray thee, unto me, and I will bless them.

    10 Now the eyes of Jacob/Israel were dim for age, so that he could not see. And he brought them near unto him; and he kissed them, and embraced them.

    11 And Israel said unto Joseph, I had not thought to see thy face: and, lo, God hath shewed me also thy seed.

    12 And Joseph brought them out from between his knees, and he bowed himself with his face to the earth.

    13 And Joseph took them both, Ephraim in his right hand toward Israel’s left hand, and Manasseh in his left hand toward Israel’s right hand, and brought them near unto him.

    14 And Israel stretched out his right hand, and laid it upon Ephraim’s head, who was the younger, and his left hand upon Manasseh’s head, guiding his hands wittingly; for Manasseh was the firstborn.

    15 And he blessed Joseph, and said, God, before whom my fathers Abraham and Isaac did walk, the God which fed me all my life long unto this day,

    16 The Angel which redeemed me from all evil, bless the lads; and let my name be named on them, and the name of my fathers Abraham and Isaac; and let them grow into a MULTITUDE IN THE MIDST OF THE EARTH.

    17 And when Joseph saw that his father laid his right hand upon the head of Ephraim, it displeased him: and he held up his father’s hand, to remove it from Ephraim’s head unto Manasseh’s head.

    18 And Joseph said unto his father, Not so, my father: for this is the firstborn; put thy right hand upon his head.

    19 And his father refused, and said, I know it, my son, I know it: HE ALSO SHALL BECOME A PEOPLE, and he also shall be GREAT: but truly his younger brother shall be GREATER than he, and his seed shall become a MULTITUDE (Commonwealth) OF NATIONS.

    20 And he blessed them that day, saying, In thee shall Israel bless, saying, God make thee as Ephraim and as Manasseh: AND HE SET EPHRAIM BEFORE MANASSEH.

    • Thanks: G J T
  62. @Gina Schrank

    Hi Gina,

    I read your comment with interest and agreement; BUT, then you blew it all at the end when you basically accuse my people of plotting for the eventual extermination of your people. You show you do NOT understand the majority of White Europeans BUT believe all the fear you have been taught.

    If Whites had wanted to exterminate you or other races they would have done it a long time ago. Around 100 years ago Whites made up over 50% of the world population and had the most advanced weapons of anyone.

    When the Tree of Life Synagogue was shot up by a crazed white man I donated to the victims, family, and Synagogue. I first went to a local Synagogue Website to see if they were taking donations but there wasn’t any but I did read about how they had a Contest for the Youth to write an Essay on the HOLOCAUST. The kids could win up to $400. The Children were being taught Fear & how to cash in on a tragedy. (I ended up going thru Go Fund Me). WE Whites, on a whole, are NOT vindictive as say, your tribe or Muslims, are. We can still reach out to help those who wish us harm in the long run and forgive.

    YOUR comment is still only about YOU and your Tribe. It does not address the many problems some of your people have caused in the West and to White people in particular (Geez, Bush put tons of Jews in charge of key positions in his Admin, just like Obomber and Biden have).

    We all get it about you folks being a minority, and that is what a Republic should address the most fairly. AMAZINGLY, your people have gained control/access to key political and economic arenas in USA and Europe, as well as the entire cultural aparatus. We now ALL get to reap the “rewards” of this profoundly sick system as we move into a New Feudalist Technocracy.

  63. @Gina Schrank

    However, let me please, as a born and raised Jew, break down the problem in much cruder terms.

    (The Jews are still fighting off the rebel Jesus, just as in the days of The Old Temple, and equally connivingly and cynically. )

    Exactly.

    Jews The Jesus Story is true, and Jew perfidy is proof of it.

    Yet most of humanity including the vast majority of true devout Christians fail to recognize Jesus’ main act of rebelliousness occurred right at the beginning of his public ministry as described in Luke 4 when he announced he was bringing an end to Jew usurious exploitation of gentiles by declaring a Jubilee of debt forgiveness.

    Luke 4 describes the oral Talmudic tradition Jews in less than one minute going from so approvingly pleased and proud of him as one of their own after he rolled up the scroll, handed it to the attendant then sat down to say “Today this scripture is fulfilled in your hearing” to attempting his murder when he continued by saying they must forgive the usurious debts they’d imposed on the out-group, not just the interest-free credit they’d extended to (((each other))).

    • Replies: @Anon
  64. G J T says:
    @Craig Nelsen

    No, we don’t need more of Judeo-Christianity, the perversion that has existed only for a fraction of Christendom’s history. A return to the Christendom of our ancestors is the antidote. The Christendom of white Europeans knowing their true identity, and the true identity of the Edomite Jews who have spent 2,000 years dedicated to the subjugation and erasure of their eternal spiritual enemy.

    Is this in the cards? Probably not.

    • Replies: @Craig Nelsen
    , @Anon
  65. Jerster says:
    @geokat62

    Saying “the other side does it too!” isn’t very elucidating, even though it is true.

  66. @Gina Schrank

    You have nothing to fear, even from the crew here that happen to know all about the nose.

    Whites are not evil murderous thugs.

  67. Anonymous[670] • Disclaimer says:
    @Dumbo

    Why don’t Jews just (sincerely) convert to Christianity? Problem solved.

    Lots of Gentiles descend from sincerely converted Jews.

    .

    The Chief Rabbi of Rome during WWII converted to Catholicism.

    In his autobiography, Before the Dawn: Autobiographical Reflections by Eugenio Zolli, Former Chief Rabbi of Rome, Zolli said that while presiding over the religious service in the synagogue on the holy day of Yom Kippur in 1944, he experienced a vision of Jesus. Within his heart, he says, he found the words “You are here for the last time.”

    …After his conversion, Zolli was asked in an interview why he had “given up the Synagogue for the Church.” Zolli responded saying, “But I have not given it up. Christianity is the completion or crown of the Synagogue. For, the Synagogue was a promise, and Christianity is the fulfillment of that promise. The Synagogue pointed to Christianity: Christianity presupposes the Synagogue. So you see, one cannot exist without the other. What I converted to was the living Christianity.”

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_Zolli

  68. JimDandy says:
    @Robert Dolan

    I don’t see that potential, outside of a remote possibility in places like Hungary, Russia, Poland, etc.

  69. @Robert Dolan

    Yet Whitey fell to his knees to suck BLM black cack after George Kirby got what he deserved,at his own hands no less…Did the WHOLE WORLD see the WHITE MAN fall to his knees to suck black cack and oil the feet of LOW IQ black ghetto trash kneegrows…Yes,Yes…I think everyone did….Like the scene in The Hateful Eight,where the White guy that Samuel L CRACKHEAD Jackson made the White guy Suck his black cack….This is what ALL the White Cuck Libertarian,Cuckservative,Liberal losers are doing…ADMIT IT NOW losers…DO IT…ADMIT what a White cuck POS losers you really are! DO IT! Admit that all of you love to slurp black shaft all day everyday because you are the weakest most corrupt degenerate POS losers the world has ever known. DO IT! NOWWWWWWW! All you DEM and LIB , LIbertarian losers are the same. You slurp 7 Eleven black cherry Slurpees everyday. You even make your White wives and Whites daughters watch so you can teach them how to properly slurp black cack. Admit it you F’in losers. DO IT!!!

  70. I appreciate the responses to my comment, even if I believe that some of them misunderstood it to a certain extent. I really have gone well out on a limb to say the things I say. And I am not defending the number of Jews killed by Hitler as being some sacrosanct number. I was simply trying to show how the mainstream Jewish community responds to any criticisms of the “holy narrative.” I have expressed elsewhere my utter outrage at the Jews for having planted the “holocaust flag” in Washington, D.C. 28 years ago with the unveiling of the “Holocaust Museum.” I believe that it signaled the transformation of the Jewish religion of antiquity into a full blown death cult that was proclaiming its victimhood as a warning to future generations of Americans not to mess with the Jews.

    Also, I didn’t mean any criticism of Mr. Joyce and his article. I appreciate it very much in fact. I just have a different way of expressing my ideas. I have simply gotten tired perhaps of over-intellectualizing a subject that is in fact a very visceral one. Academic discussions are very valuable, but sometimes they miss the horror and ultimate truth of the underlying reality.

    • Replies: @plannumber9
  71. AndrewR says:
    @Caspar Von Everec

    There are people in Madagascar. What did they ever do to you?

    The solution is to destroy Israel and make everything that’s “good for the Jews” punishable by death.

    • Replies: @anon
  72. @Fisk Ellington Rutledge IV

    wow! I don’t see myself anywhere in that picture there above. and I did not enslave myself, steal my own labor, pogrom and racist myself: I did not create white police forces and sic them on myself, have not invaded white nations and stole all they had.

    I see cause and effect as the meter of existence… you reap what you sow. what’s the difference between whites and Jews then? none that I can see! whites are liars, cheats and thieves…but also mass murderers, unconscionable racists etc.

    Look at this! the president of Tanzania was just killed. He sought to protect his people from the Covid and the vaccines openly. he died! how many Black leaders have been so assassinated? they did not kill themselves…white people killed them.

    for 300 years you stole Black labor in the USA them you ‘freed’ the slaves, let them go with nothing at all…no food, clothes, homes…NO COMPENSATION! AFTER CENTURIES OF TRAUMATIC DEPRIVATION OF THEIR LABOR!!

    imagine that eh. and they are still here, managed to survive and even increase their numbers, under another 160 years plus of intense deprivation that were as bad or even worse than the very slavery itself.

    and look at that eh! the Jews who are white people just like yourself, have taken over your space and they have not- at least not yet- really got to the enslavement part relative to you as yet. they are still at the vaccine stage… and you know if they insist that you get vaccinated there is something in it for you that will make you their direct slave.

    Interesting~ cause and effect! what goes around… and look at how you scream already!!

    you have not been yet forced to work a day of slave labor yet and hear your screams!!

    but your screams do not hide the fact of your own true, expressed above stupidity. and STUPIDITY IT IS LOUD AND CLEAR!! ALL THESE CENTURIES AND YOU ARE STILL AS STUPID AS ANY ORIGINAL REDNECK!!!

    you beliefs are idiotic, inaccurate and first rate stupid. there are no superior people.

    all the ideologies you can possibly subscribe to as an American right wing nut, are well known and they are all idiotic. which is why you are in the position you are in, developing in font your face, nasty for you and there is little to nothing you can do to stop it. you don’t know how. and you are making enemies of those like yourself by social class, who have the same social interest as you do, without whose support you have no chance at all, less the greater chance you would have if they fought with you, by your side

    as I sit here I can count a ton of Black people who are far far superior to you in some many ways. lots and lots of Black men prettier than you as well. would you like me to post up some pictures of truly handsome Black men, well muscled, tall, physically smooth and strong, bright, articulate achieved, the kind of men most women love, women who would leave you standing there, by yourself. while they go check out those guys…Black men all. men against whom, on all levels of life, you lose!

    I am pissed off by your idiocy. you are so stupid you portend our loss, the loss of all ordinary people against the Jewish/Elitist interest in society..at this stage of fundamental social change, driven by technological advance and comprehensive western capitalist failure. you are so stupid you cannot make common cause with the rest of humanity because they are people of color. and you are representative of a large group of ordinary people who cannot be counted on in the struggle.

    and given your extreme nonsense above, by no means a secret, if you do try to make common cause we cant trust you because when the win is achieved we can expect you to turn on us, to try kill us off.

    what a stupid, loud waste of time you are! fortunately however you are not all WHITE…all white people that is. there are those who make some sense. you can keep your stupid self where you belong..in white redneck, superior delusion-land

    a true nasty jackass! what the hell is the difference between he and Jews he curses! and I let him piss me off!

    • Replies: @Franklin Ryckaert
  73. @G J T

    Edomite Jews? Weren’t the Edomites one of the many peoples the Jews completely exterminated?

  74. Where is Jeff Gates? Is he still alive?

    His youtube interviews on RedIce and elsewhere, about his book, Guilt by Association, have been canceled.

    The topic of Gates’s book was the “transgenerational transnational criminal syndicate” dominated by Jews that Gates was tempted to identify as zionism.

    This review of his book, Guilt by Association, provides a great deal of information that was not available even in Gates’s interviews. It is by former Amb. Andrew Killgore published by Grant Smith’s organization, WRMEA (Washington Report on Middle East Affairs):
    https://www.wrmea.org/008-november/books-guilt-by-association-how-deception-and-self-deceit-took-america-to-war.html

    [MORE]

    QUOTED MATERIAL:
    Review
    “Guilt By Association is an initially confusing masterpiece almost too stuffed with evidence to concentrate on making clear its basic theme. But author Jeff Gates did so in a recent letter to a distinguished retired American diplomat: The research pivoted off the firsthand experience of John Doe whose experience spans 56 years of dealing with a transnational criminal syndicate whose senior operatives share a common ideology in fundamental Judaism and a skill set experienced in displacing facts with beliefs. Thus the common source of the fixed intelligence that took us to war in Iraq. And, thus the same network now being employed to expand this war to Iran.

    From 1980 to 1987 Gates served as counsel to the Senate Finance Committee, working with Sen. Russell Long of Louisiana, son of the state s former Gov. Huey Long, who was assassinated at age 42 as he was preparing a presidential campaign. James Farley, postmaster general under President Franklin Roosevelt, had run a penny postcard poll confirming that if Huey Long actually ran for president, Roosevelt could not be re-elected.

    Fifty years later Russell Long remained convinced that Roosevelt s people had killed his father. At a 2002 speech Gates gave in London, he met John Doe, related to one of the well-known people who had endorsed two of Gates earlier books. Soon afterward, Doe assured him that if Gates undertook the research and analysis the results of which appear in Guilt, the evidence would identify who killed Huey Long, and why.

    The facts Gates assembled point not to Roosevelt s people but to the syndicate identified in Guilt.

    The future multi-volume Criminal State series will chronicle the operations of an international criminal syndicate as experienced by John Doe since his birth in 1952. Gates and Doe have worked together in Arizona for the past three years documenting the deeply criminal activities of the syndicate whose schemes encompass geopolitical goals achieved through corruption and ruthlessness. Because control of the Oval Office is the syndicate’s goal, the immediate purpose of Guilt is to alert the public to the perils of John McCain emerging as president and commander-in-chief. McCain s election would embolden those skilled at displacing facts with deceit, Gates documents with convincing detail. The brilliantly provocative Guilt by Association consists of nine chapters: Game Theory and the Mass Murder of 9/11 ; Organized Crime in Arizona ; John McCain and Financial Frauds ; McCain Family Secret: The Cover-Up ; The Presidency and Russian Organized Crime ; Money, Democracy and the Great Divide ; The New Anti-Semitism ; Would Obama Be Better? ; and The Way Forward.

    In the first chapter Gates illustrates the intergenerational sophistication with which neoconservatives prepared the minds of the American public to invade Iraq in response to 9/11. Academics and think tanks pushed Samuel Huntington s 1996 Clash of Civilizations to promote a clash consensus five years before 9/11. That same year Richard Perle along with other neocons such as Douglas Feith wrote A Clean Break: A New Strategy for Securing the Realm for incoming Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu. This helped lay more mental threads for removing Saddam Hussain. Then Senators McCain, Joe Lieberman, a Jewish Zionist from Connecticut, and Jon Kyl, a Christian Zionist from Arizona, co-sponsored the Iraq Liberation Act of 1998. Distracted by the Monica Lewinsky affair, President Bill Clinton signed it. –Andrew I. Killgore, co-founder of WRMEA and former U.S. Ambassador to Qatar

    Four days after the destruction of the World Trade Towers, then Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz was urging President George W. Bush to invade Iraq. Not only was there was no evidence that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction, but there was no real connection between Saddam s secular regime and the deeply religious al-Qaeda.

    At the same time, other Zionists from the U.S. Defense Department under Wolfowitz and, not so coincidentally, Feith were feeding false intelligence to the White House. The war would not be costly, according to Wolfowitz, and the entirely unnecessary and illegal war was launched. In his chapter on John McCain and the Financial Frauds, Gates reviews McCain s unsavory role in the Keating Five scandal. The following chapter recounts the shameful role of McCain s father in helping to cover up Israel s deliberate attack on the USS Liberty during the 1967 Six-Day War in which 34 of the crew were killed and 294 wounded. From a game theory perspective, Gates explains, by covering up the murder of Americans aboard the USS Liberty, a U.S. president (with the aid of Admiral John McCain, Jr.) confirmed that Israeli extremists could murder Americans without endangering U.S. support. [see https://www.unz.com/article/movie-review-sacrificing-liberty/ Movie Review: Sacrificing Liberty
    The day the world was six minutes from WW3
    BRIAN R. WRIGHT • APRIL 5, 2021; or rent/purchase Sacrificing Liberty https://www.trunews.com/stream/sacrificing-liberty-docu-series-official-trailer ]

    In the chapter on The Presidency and Russian Organized Crime, Gates describes a John McCain who was either ignorant about or complicit in Russian organized crime. During Boris Yeltsin s first term as president of Russia, a handful of oligarchs financially pillaged Russia. Six of the Big Seven oligarchs, whom Gates terms Ashkenazis, qualify for Israeli citizenship. McCain described Mikhail Khodorkovsky, the most infamous of Russia s corrupt oil oligarchs, as a political prisoner. Notes Gates: To claim Khodorkovsky as a political prisoner requires a closer look at how, at 32 years of age, a single Russian-Ashkenazi citizen amassed state-owned assets worth more than $30 billion. Gates goes on to document the widespread criminality involved in Khodorkovsky s billions. To solve this systemic criminality, Gates explains, requires that a broad base of Americans understand how this fields-within-fields modus operandi operates unseen yet in plain sight, and how its operations progress working through people whose profiled needs become the means for influencing their behavior. Guilt describes how Americans were induced to freely choose the very forces that endanger their freedom. Thus the role of those masterful at waging war by deception (the motto of the Israeli Mossad) by displacing facts with what the mark (i.e., the U.S.) could be deceived to believe: for example, that Iraq had nuclear weapons and mobile biological weapons laboratories and that the secular Saddam Hussein had ties with the fundamentalists of al-Qaeda. Crafted as a wake-up call, the author documents how Tel Aviv wields control over U.S. foreign policy in an environment where lawmakers have been intimidated by the Israel lobby.

    U.S. national security, Gates writes, requires a rejection of the self-deception that Israel operates as a trustworthy ally in an unstable region while ignoring its multi-decade role in provoking and sustaining instability. As Gates points out, the charge of anti-Semitism is used to misdirect and intimidate. As the criminality he documents becomes transparent, moderate Jews in fact are emerging as allies. The Zionist component which Gates convincingly portrays as ideology in the service of criminality has as its goal an extensive, Jews-only realm in an oil-rich region.

    The facts confirm that Tel Aviv will never agree to peace with the Palestinians, as that would preclude their expansionist agenda for a Greater Israel. An oft-employed entropy strategy remains Israel s means to preclude settlement of the conflict. Indeed, Huntington s Clash of Civilizations is revealed as only the latest in a long series of manipulations each of which is designed to ensure a plausible evildoer. Meanwhile, fundamentalist Jews catalyze serial conflicts of opposites, while this transnational criminal syndicate profits off the misery of both. “–Andrew I. Killgore (WRMEA Review)
    END QUOTE

    • Thanks: Pheasant, Mustapha Mond
    • Replies: @SolontoCroesus
  75. @SolontoCroesus

    from a 2017 Reader’s Review of Jeff Gates’s Guilt by Association on the Amazon site:

    The Jews must be fought on every front. Being smeared as an Antisemite should be worn proudly as a badge of honor. Open rancorous discussion must be fought for. The Holocaust lie must be exposed. The State of Israel must be openly exposed.

    Without a media outlet America is doomed. The mass media must be taken back from the Jews. Without control of the media, America is lost. Israel controls our media.

    So the fight must be on a grass roots level. Every American needs to wake up, turn off the TV and read and then stand tall. Imagine if everyone you meet tells you openly the Holocaust is a Zionist Propaganda piece designed to enslave the world. Israel will cease to exist.

    Imagine if we can turn the table on Congress and make it reprehensible for a congressman / congresswoman to embrace Israel.

    • Replies: @ben sampson
  76. RestiveUs says:
    @Caspar Von Everec

    I remember an Austrian guy from about 80 years ago who was working on that…

  77. Anon[264] • Disclaimer says:
    @Farrakhan.DDuke.AliceWalker.AllAgree

    Jews The Jesus Story is true, and Jew perfidy is proof of it.

    Indeed, that is the only thing left that draws me back to Christianity for another look, the fact that the Jews hate it so much, and so openly.

    If such a repellent people hate something with such focus, can it really be bad?

  78. I don’t think that anyone on the far right has any desire to harm jewish people.

    The issue is the disproportionate jewish influence that is wrecking the entire western world.

    The solution is to remove jews from those positions of influence…..a quota system might work.

    If jews were 2% in media, 2% in academia, 2% in finance, government, etc., that might correct some of the problems.

    Control of the FED is also a huge issue.

    Campaign finance needs to be addressed.

    Seems to me that organized jewry should listen to the complaints and make the proper corrections. That’s probably naive on my part, but I’d rather see a peaceful solution.

    As whites wake up to the reality of jewish tyranny…..organized jewry will absolutely NOT be able to play whack a mole when the game involves 100 million (or more) white Christian people, many of whom are armed.
    Force won’t work in the long run. As white people see the unfairness and brutality, people become radicalized…..and that is happening right at this moment.

    Another aspect to consider is that as people around the world see what is being done to whites in America, some will speak out in protest. Israel is already unpopular on the world stage.

    The anti-white regime is winning at the moment, but whites have been caught off guard and many don’t understand what is happening. As the brainwashing wears off there will surely be a reaction from the demonized and victimized whites. In fact, it’s obvious that the jewish elite expects a reaction as they got Biden to sign an unconstitutional EO to steal people’s assets if they are whimsically labeled as “Russian colluders.” I know it sounds absurd, but this is what the dumb bastards are doing. They are poking the bear right in the eye……another beta test to see how much they can get away with.

  79. Religious groups that are as Democratic as Jews are in the US include atheists, agnostics, Orthodox Christian, Unitarian, United Church of Christ, Episcopal and Seventh Day Adventist.

    https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/02/23/u-s-religious-groups-and-their-political-leanings/

    Joyce and his readers need a group to blame for their psychological failings. Jews are the most convenient. Any excuse will do.

    There needs be no more commentary.

    • Replies: @Mulga Mumblebrain
    , @Janus
  80. anon[334] • Disclaimer says:
    @AndrewR

    Area between Egypt and S. Arabia available for
    50 million Yid. A little compacting maybe needed

  81. @Gina Schrank

    Great comment Gina, but when do monetary reparations begin for what your filth race owes us?

    • Agree: Publius 2
  82. @unwoke

    I remember Vanessa Redgrave getting an Oscar, and eloquently and forthrightly condemning the Zionists in her speech. The were some mutters and boos in allergic reaction to the truth, but today no such honesty would be tolerated. If not dragged kicking or screaming off the stage, or lynched behind the scenes, the ‘antisemite’ would ‘never work in Hollywood anymore’, and possibly have the US Judaic Jusrtice Department on their heels, from then on. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. Meanwhile, that fine Sabbat Goy, Starmer, continues the work that the UK Jewish Board of Deputies gave him, and is busy destroying what is left of UK Labour.

    • Agree: Mustapha Mond
    • Replies: @geokat62
  83. @Triteleia Laxa

    How many Seventh Day Adventists are in Bidet’s Cabinet? How many United Church of Christ adherents run hedge funds? How many Unitarians run one of the six media Empires?

    • Replies: @Triteleia Laxa
  84. @Robert Dolan

    Jews lived pretty peacefully with their host societies in Mesopotamia after the Roman expulsion, and under the Ottomans and in al-Andaluce, when strong central Government protected them, and refused to tolerate any parasitical activities by them. A simple solution. Jews can be authors, musicians, comedians, artists, architects etc, but they are forbidden to work in the financial gangster industry. Ban the goyim from that activity, too, while you’re at it. Simples.

  85. @ben sampson

    “…as I sit here I can count a ton of Black people who are far far superior to you in some many ways…”*)

    You mean when Blacks take over a city such as Detroit?

    Two examples will be enough:

    1) What is left over of the library:

    2) What is left over of the auto industry:

    If there is still some civilization left in the US, send for the Black Looting Matters crowd:

    _________________________

    *)”some many” is a contradiction in terms. I leave it to your Black genius to figure out why that is the case.

    • Replies: @ben sampson
    , @John Johnson
  86. Anon[264] • Disclaimer says:
    @noname27

    White Caucasians are The True Israelites – God’s Chosen Race (NOT JEWS).

    So, Christian Identity’s still a thing, eh?

    Wow, so retro, so 80’s.

    • Replies: @noname27
  87. I grew up in a predominantly Jewish neighborhood, Elementary thru College. In Elementary School, I remember painting Jewish symbols for holidays on the windows. 99% of my friends were Jewish.
    They never, repeat, never referred to themselves as white. There were white guys, black guys, some Asians, and them. Jewish girls would rarely date white guys, although it was not discussed, it was obvious and well known. I dated a Jewish girl for 2-3 yrs in College, she never told her parents about me, and snuck out of the house to see me. Here sister new me, but she also kept the secret from her family.
    Jews do not see themselves as white, they see themselves as a separate (and better) class based not only on religion, but also family culture. A Jew is just as likely to marry a white as a black, which is not to say it does not happen, but they would view it as the same thing. To understand their agenda, one must understand them and how they see themselves (and us).

    • Replies: @Franklin Ryckaert
  88. hillaire says:
    @noname27

    British ‘israelism’ a creation of financial ‘jews’ in the 19th century to facilitate a bending of english identity ( very important to the jews) and adherance to their ’empire’ run through the ‘east india ‘ company’ anglo/dutch heh heh… it fell flat as a pancake, like the rancorous ‘disraeli’ and his torpid revelatory scribblings.
    work that one through me old mucker..

    like the protestants the puritans the quakers etc etc all cogs in the ‘jewish’ revolutionary ‘engine’..

    one could add masonry, kabalism, rosicrucianism, illuminism, etc etc..

    historically speaking the tribes, scythian connection etc are all true and foundational euro myth/history, one doesn’t have to hitch ones cart to jewish devil gods for this to be true.. nor that the aristos in europe on the whole are descended from byzantine semites and are probably ‘jews’ of a sort themselves….

    but anti-semites masquerading as ‘chosen jews’ is ridiculous, a problem the national socialists and their germanic zionism encountered, many were in fact ‘jews’ themselves of course…

    but in the end they were merely pieces on a chess board moved by the ancient financialists and that includes the midget georgian iron man starling and adolph shekel grubber..

    • Replies: @noname27
  89. DanFromCT says:

    Obviously there are warm and delightful Jewish people, even in NYC, hard as that is to believe. The thing is, Andrew Joyce’s academic analysis misses the true interaction between Jews and non-Jews in a place like New York City where it matters. You could sum up the attitude you’ll come across as that which one woman screeched at my sister-in-law, “We Jews shit on you Christians.”

    Just vocalize the word “Jew” in a restaurant or other venue in NYC and it’d be as if you’d called for their extermination–the frightened manager will be over to your table and ask you to leave in a NY second. Their paranoia is in their DNA, as a matter of fact. They imagine that the hatred they feel toward you is what you’re thinking about them. They really do imagine they have the magical Freudian power to hear what you’re saying, but know what you’re really thinking.

    This tepid academic evaluation is important, of course, I understand that, but unless you’ve worked with Jews and for Jews, say on Wall Street and a related field, as I have, it’s probably the case that you, like Andrew Joyce, may intellectually comprehend the hatred Jews have for you, but because you haven’t lived it and emotionally internalized it, you’re not motivated to prevent a repeat of what they as Bolsheviks did to 60+ million Russians merely for being white Christians. They will bury you, they will turn your children’s lives into hell on earth as they did in Russia, because for them, it’s an existential war, and not just an interesting, limp-wristed read now and then like it is here.

  90. Anon[106] • Disclaimer says:
    @G J T

    The Jewish author in the Jew Testament book of Philippians says, “We are the circumcision.” The Jewish author of 1 Corinthians states, “Christ our Passover lamb is sacrificed.” Who else identifies themselves by the cruel genital mutilation practice of the Jews and celebrates the Jewish child sacrifice holiday but Jews? I name the Jew. You. Even the Vicar of Christ says, “Inside every Christian is a Jew.”

    Yoo da Joo!

  91. Monopduly says: • Website
    @Mario Partisan

    Seattle, Portland, Austin: these are not centers of Jewish influence. White, gentile, liberals are quite sufficient for the generation of degeneracy, and dysgenic white decline. In evolutionary terms, what we are witnessing is the incipient speciation of a human intraspecific social parasite, and the corrupting influence of its intermediary, ‘meritocracy’, designed for phenotypic manipulation of the host. The economics are neo-feudal, bilateral monopsony, i.e., Monopduly:

    https://www.academia.edu/46936294/Ethno_Nationalism_as_Host_Evasion_Under_Intraspecific_Social_Parasitism_with_Phenotypic_Manipulation

  92. anarchyst says:

    One can call a jew a shyster, shylock, money-grubbing bankster, Christ-killer, or other derogatory term and it will roll off his back like water off a duck, but call a jew a “jew” and he will recoil in horror, having been “found out”.
    Despite their supremacist attitude, ((they)) are extremely afraid of being identified as “jews”.

    • Agree: Pheasant
  93. @Robert Dolan

    you are missing the point. the changes you list cannot come about by wishing them as you do above. they cannot come about by negotiations or elections or anything of the kind. the only people with an interest in those changes, who will benefit from them are we, the ordinary people.

    therefore the only people who can bring them are the ordinary people out in the streets overwhelming the status quo, which will happen if the people actually see the truth of the day, their real condition in the society at this stage, and what they are doing is the only way to solve their problems.

    and that is indeed the truth! popular take over of society is the only way forward for the people. all else is Brave New world full of mandated compulsory vaccinations.

    the people must take over and create in the process ways that meet ordinary interest in society as they go. one development is likely to help massively and that is administrative break of large countries. American is likely to break up into its constituent parts and that would really allow the people to be creative in response to their overall needs. it would be more facile at the state or such popular administrative process to start small

    and the smaller the parts the easier it would be to avoid political parties and all minority power organizations that do not directly produce wealth for themselves. of course they would be the counter to what the people do popularly…the parasitic counter revolution who would betray the people iof they were allowed to take power.

    under no circumstance must the people fall back into any political arrangement or administrative organization that allows politics as usual as we know politics that we do currently to prevail. that would be counter-revolution straight, and right back where they started from. the people themselves must make totally hands-on democratic organization with all involved. they must make organic connective popular organization an systematic set ups in which very quickly decisions can be made and implemented by all or most

    that has been achieved already the last time I believe in Hungary 19-fifites. the Hungarians begged the world, Europe to protect their democratic worker state and that if they were to survive they would show the world how successful a real popular democracy could be. the Russian Soviet state invaded and crushed them.

    but that’s the human future if we are to have one. there is no way the Jews can do any different than they are doing right now trying to save their power and wealth and lives. they will kill us all if they have to. and it would be the same regardless who the elites were, who came to be as they are now from the system in place…right, elite nd on top from a system of total exploitation of the majority of the people, wealthy from constant crime against humanity.

    it is the system we have lived for so long that has now run its course and must evolve into another of the possible ways available, that resolves the obvious and fundamental problems of the day, problems that absolutely must be resolved at this time, from the angles/interests of the people involved: from the rich they must make a world in which they are totally in charge and cannot be challenged by the ordinary folk.

    that means depopulation, permanent masking and social distancing of the those who remain: and ultimately genetically engineering of ordinary folk into permanent imbecility, that cannot rise in revolution.

    the ordinary people to save themselves, must rise now in revolution, overwhelm and overthrow the rich elitist state, and create the democracy I tried to describe above or in whatever way they find necessary on the day and as they go…directly controlled and run by the ordinary people for the ordinary people elimination all administrative organizational structures that can or may hide a counter-revolution.

    what you talking about there is a dream. it can’t happen that way – be resolved that way. that is not the way society actually works. we have arrived and a point of resolution and the trouble has only now begun. you should research and develop yourself to meet this day from the basis of you own social class or you will be consumed without a fight, maybe even convinced to act against your own class interest.

  94. @Franklin Ryckaert

    we learned all of that from you Franklin.

    what!!? don’t forget to remember you are the chosen and the example we must follow. the devastation of America? that’s you!

    Black American still on a lower level than you. we do not modify the food genetically yet. the way things are going we wont get the chance…killed off by the very modified food; or Covid vaccinations

  95. @Mulga Mumblebrain

    Joyce was criticising them for their beliefs, not complimenting them for being good at their jobs.

  96. A123 says:
    @DanFromCT

    the true interaction between Jews and non-Jews in a place like New York City where it matters.

    NYC generally, and Manhattan specifically, do not matter.

    Name any significant Manhattanite that does not have a massive ego. Al Sharpton is NYC. So is Donald Trump. Granny Killer Cuomo is a paragon of NYC incivility. You should blame Chuck Schumer for being a piece of human detritus with NYC values. Most observant Jews would like to disown the scum bag.

    Can we give Manhattan back to the Native American Indians? Please? They have to keep the residents though….. They can have Elizabeth Warren too.

    PEACE 😇

  97. Janus says:
    @Triteleia Laxa

    Unfortunately, the link you posted doesn’t support your claims in most instances. Jews: 64% Democrat. Orthodox, Episcopal, Seventh Day Adventist, and United Church of Christ: 49%, 44%, 45%, and 58%, respectively. Also interesting to note that two of the remaining three “religious groups” you list are atheists and agnostics.

  98. Hossein says:
    @Marckus

    There are Blacks in Israel, they are the flashsa Ethiopian Jews , brought in to be used as propaganda tools to show so called diversity in Judenland even though most White East European Zionists abhor Blacks .

  99. geokat62 says:
    @Mulga Mumblebrain

    Meanwhile, that fine Sabbat Goy, Starmer, continues the work that the UK Jewish Board of Deputies gave him, and is busy destroying what is left of UK Labour.

    Spot on.

  100. @No Country for Wight Men

    Jews may not see themselves as “white”, but if they intermarry it is mostly with Whites, and intermarriage among them is high, especially among the non-religious:

    “…The new Pew Research survey finds that, overall, 56% of married Jews have a Jewish spouse, while 44% of Jewish respondents are married to a non-Jew. Among Jews by religion who are married, 64% have a Jewish spouse and 36% have a non-Jewish spouse. By comparison, Jews of no religion are much more likely to be in mixed marriages; just 21% of married Jews of no religion are married to a Jewish spouse, while 79% are married to a non-Jewish spouse…”

    Source: Pew Research Center Jewish American Intermarriage Patterns and Other…
    https://www.pewforum.org

  101. @SolontoCroesus

    “Without a media outlet America is doomed. The mass media must be taken back from the Jews. Without control of the media, America is lost. Israel controls our media.”

    We don’t have to read or look at the Jewish media you know!

    In the meantime lots of media can now be made cost effectively, that can replace the Jewish media if the people would do what they should do- Boycott the Jewish media in favor of the new ones made by the people for the people!

    already there is much of alternative media on the net. if the people start to boycott a lot more can be made. the people should boycott in particular Twitter and Facebook and ordinary people should make such media of their own

    it makes little sense that Twitter and Facebook are still going. both of those should have been boycotted already and new alternative, like media should have been growing healthily in their place.

  102. @Dumbo

    The idea behind the creation of “israel” was to steal some real estate and call it a country. So you could make your own laws. And have a safe place for all your spies, assassins, murderers, embezzlers, grifters, thieves, and scam artists. Pollarded and Maxwelled!

  103. anon[204] • Disclaimer says:

    I guess it is commendable to hold jews to account one way or another; which unz doesn’t do, but can you imagine how boring it is to have jews hog the limelight all the time on sites like this?
    I’m tired of it.
    People like me want solutions more than we want more problems. Solutions are not age old political lies which have besieged countless generations since the beginning of Witchcraft. Solutions are changes in government, in the way government is run and how to keep those greedy pricks out of our lives as much as possible. Solutions do not include exchanging tweedle dum for tweedle dee in the next election.
    The only solution is changing how government works. In the same way that the only solution to environmental destruction is to buy the environment. Little people grouping together and buying the land at issue, buying the terrorist groups against us for comfort and so on.

    • Replies: @Father Coughlin
  104. Art says:

    Left wing Jews, right wing Jews – who cares. The devil is not in the details – the devil is the tribe.

    Our problem is TRIBAL Jews. It makes no difference to America’s future, which Jew prevails. The Jew MSM controls both the left wing and the right wing politics in the US. The Jew moneyed elite of the left and the right both dictate the US government Israeli policy.

    The important division of Jews is – Zionist – not-Zionist. The Zionist Jews of America are not a detail – they are an overwhelming fact. I have seen it commented, that 85% of US Jews are hard core Zionists.

    If there are 10,000,000 Jews in America that means that you will need 8,500,000 different boxes to check describing different stripes of Israeli supporting Jews.

    How many articles have been on Unz trying to parse different shades of Jews?

    There is only one division of importance to the world – Zionist – not-Zionist.

    p.s. All the other divisions are a ruse and an insnaring trap, directing us away from what is important to Western culture.

    • Agree: Robert Dolan
    • Replies: @Zumbuddi
  105. Zumbuddi says:
    @Art

    Defining characteristic of “Jew,” Left, Right, atheist, zionist, not Zionist is holding on to holocaust narrative.

    Time for non-Jews to declaim their own history and stop being defined by Jews-ADL.

    Why are our children taught to feel sorry for Anne Frank but not Mary Phagan?

  106. @Gina Schrank

    (snip)Finally, I, as a rebellious Jew with a conscience, won’t be spared any more than the clearly demonic Jews who are currently leading the movement to destroy our country (Zuckerberg, Soros, et. al.) For on the day of reckoning, as my mother warned me, all Jews will be treated as one by the Gentiles. If she is right, there is thus no escape for me. But life is fleeting anyway, so I might as well give it my best shot.(end)

    The fact that you turned the end of your piece into a self-absorbed kvetch, is proof of your Judaism.

  107. Jews can live in free Gentile societies, the same way a cat with sharp claws can live in a house. It just has to be belled. Fortunately, the Jewish Internet, of all things, has given us a trustworthy bell: it has never been more simple to find out who is Jewish and who is not. And thus “caveat emptor” with respect to any dealings.

  108. We are 300 years into a judeo-satanic revolution. We don’t have time to screw around and parse the jews on the head of a pin.
    1666 Sabatai Zevi goes Muslim, takes over 100,000 fanatics and lunatics with him into a secret society known as the Doenmeh Jews. They scheme to murder 200,000 Armenians in the 1880’s then kill 1.5 million Christians in 1920
    1717-merger of FreeMasonry and the Illuminati. Some kind of Jewish banking alliance established in support.
    1776- America Revolution: FreeMason project established to use America as an international base
    French Revolution: How many die before Napoleon, a FreeMason, is stopped?
    1848 Revolutions
    WW1 First War for Israel. How many dead?
    1917 Russian Revolution: How many millions die?
    WW2 2nd War for Israel. 65 Million die.
    2021 Insanity Prevails

    We are seriously sitting here parsing jewish hairs on a pin? Really? While the Titanic sinks, we polish brass?
    We have very little time. We need to end the American Insanity by force, seize the records of FreeMasonry and all Zionist orgs then begin mass trials for crimes against humanity with death sentences for the guilty. We have very little time left before they consolidate power and execute 7 Billion people.

    • Agree: Publius 2
  109. @anon

    I guess it is commendable to hold jews to account one way or another; which unz doesn’t do, but can you imagine how boring it is to have jews hog the limelight all the time on sites like this?
    I’m tired of it.
    People like me want solutions more than we want more problems. Solutions are not age old political lies which have besieged countless generations since the beginning of Witchcraft. Solutions are changes in government, in the way government is run and how to keep those greedy pricks out of our lives as much as possible. (snip)

    This itself is a Jewish trick. It’s like “You want to stop us? Legislate something, goy!”. No. Why don’t I just stop *you* and then I don’t have to worry about coming up with the neutral language to put in a bill? 😂

  110. Jay Fink says:

    You just never know. I was born into a Reform Jewish family. I am very secular and non-religious. I think of Judaism as my ethnicity not my religion. I don’t have a religion. On paper I should be a flaming leftist. Yet I am a right winger, far to the right of the Republican party.

  111. JM says:
    @Desert Fox

    “The zionists have hijacked the Jews and led them into communism…”

    Your knowledge is shallow. Zionism was the enemy of Communism and this intensified over time till it totally dissociated from it. BTW, the “Central Banks” issue a tiny proportion of the money in any economy.

    • Replies: @geokat62
  112. geokat62 says:
    @JM

    Your knowledge is shallow. Zionism was the enemy of Communism…

    Not according to author, Douglas Reed. Excerpt from The Controversy of Zion:

    Thus these two movements [Zionism and Communism] appeared at first sight to be fixedly opposed to each other- for the one made nationalism its religion, even its god, and the other declared war to the death on nationalism. This antagonism was only apparent, and in truth the two movements ran on parallel tracks, not head on towards a collision on the same line, “for the god who promised land to the nation to be gathered-in also promised to set it “above all people that are upon the face of the earth” and to destroy all other nations ··with a mighty destruction until they be destroyed”. The world-revolution, which pursued the second of these aims, thus fulfilled the condition set for the first of them; either by accident or by design, it too was doing the will of Jehovah…

    • Thanks: Robjil
  113. moi says:
    @LarryS

    Israel is NOT a secular state.

  114. ShawnW says:
    @Gina Schrank

    You are right (www.realjewsnews.com). However, you need to abandon your Satanic FALSE religion of Talmudism. Embrace the fulfillment of the religion of the Old Testament – the Catholic Church. However, DON’T follow Antipope Francis (https://www.tcwblog.com/182861450).

  115. ShawnW says:
    @Robert Dolan

    It is horrible that the only people outside of a few evangelical Protestants, true Catholics, and Muslims who are against the Jews are racists. No Jew should ever be in a position of power because they can’t be trusted. Nothing in government, media, education, finance, etc.

  116. noname27 says: • Website
    @Anon

    What good fortune for you that there is no premium on ignorance.

    TRUE British Israel is NOT Christian Identity.

    Christian Identity is stuffed with fraudsters and liars e.g. James Wickstrom (deceased), Bertrand Comparet (deceased) and William (Bill) Finck (Christogenea) the ex-con lying Jew.

    WOW! So up to date and so 2020’s

  117. noname27 says: • Website
    @hillaire

    Oh dear, yet another pompous jack ass who delusionally thinks he’s informed.

    British Israel IS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE JEWS. British Israel is not an ‘ism’ and is our TRUE HISTORY. The Bible is nothing to do with The Jews.

    Go to my blog (representing 35 years work – link above) and educate yourself and come back in 5 years when you have learned something. I won’t be holding my breath.

  118. Publius 2 says:

    This article deserved more comments.

  119. hillaire says:

    Thanks for the offer, but I’m quite familiar with ‘identity’ and it’s cultish followers, that’s not to say their isn’t some merit in what you say..

    but the biggest problem you have is the ‘good book’ was compiled by ‘greeks’ and ‘pharisaic jews’ after the babylonian captivity.. so there is that..

    but here is the kicker for you dimwits, it ‘is’ based on ancient aryan legend and quite obviously deals with a caucasian people, the ancient egyptians were genetically identical to the british people as genetic tests attest. (king tut genetic profiling). and it is already accepted that the near east was populated with caucasians before the mixing with dravidians and sub-saharan negro slaves.. all ancient texts attest to this, the ‘jews’ just inserted themselves into a collection of ancient sumerian and babylonian myths (some of even more ancient origin) after twisting the narrative.. hence the burning of alexandria.

    it is the ridiculous parroting of the devil god nonsense I take exception to… it should be decoupled from the new testament as the ancient church fathers advised..

    then imbeciles like yourself could focus on educating yourself on the ‘true nature’ of euro man decoupled from these ridiculous mixed ‘jews’…..

  120. @Franklin Ryckaert

    Most of the authors in that library were probably racist and had it coming.

  121. @DanFromCT

    Cherishing Andrew Joyce’s efforts and work product does not preclude treasuring your comment here.

    Old saying: “Always trust the sense of a man with an experience over that of a man with an idea.”

    Psychopathic to the extreme:

    They imagine that the hatred they feel toward you is what you’re thinking about them.

    Thank you for sharing this monumental insight learned up close and personal full time:

    …but unless you’ve worked with Jews and for Jews, say on Wall Street and a related field, as I have, it’s probably the case that you, like Andrew Joyce, may intellectually comprehend the hatred Jews have for you, but because you haven’t lived it and emotionally internalized it, you’re not motivated to prevent a repeat of what they as Bolsheviks did to 60+ million Russians merely for being white Christians. They will bury you, they will turn your children’s lives into hell on earth as they did in Russia, because for them, it’s an existential war

    Your insights resulting from direct interpersonal work interface are particularly appreciated here because although the innovative business venture was stolen by (((them))) and (((their))) control of the Jewdiciary thwarted recovery clearly mandated by law, all of which resulted in the breakup of the home via Jew-Fault Divorce, all that happened without direct interface. They did it by creeping out of sight.

    You saw the face of diabolical Jew evil on a daily basis up close and personal.

    Have often wondered how some of the shabby goyim of Wall Street and other Jew industries like politics survive and often thrive; is it luck of the draw or is a kindred amorality the key trait?

  122. @Gina Schrank

    Full blown death cult exactly describes it. Whatever numbers were true during WWII, I don’t know, but many peoples have experienced genocide at some point. It does not make you special, much less superior or the Greatest Ever Victim.

  123. How does one explain the phenomenon that Jews and Southerners voted in tandem for decades until 1964, including in obscene proportions for outright traitors? What do these superficially different demographics have in common that would clarify this?

  124. Sam J. says:
    @G J T

    “…With very few exceptions, a Jew is a Jew is a Jew is a Jew…”

    Exactly. There’s not enough of them on our side to make a difference and no matter if they say they are not the problem or not they don’t do enough to stop those that are.

Current Commenter
says:

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone


 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Andrew Joyce Comments via RSS